A group of ecologists led by Axel Mithöfer at the Max Planck Institute for Chemical Ecology in Germany examined the...
GMAT Standard English Conventions : (Grammar) Questions
A group of ecologists led by Axel Mithöfer at the Max Planck Institute for Chemical Ecology in Germany examined the defensive responses of two varieties of the sweet potato ______ TN57, which is known for its insect resistance, and TN66, which is much more susceptible to pests.
Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?
plant.
plant;
plant
plant:
Let's begin by understanding the meaning of this sentence. We'll use our understanding of pause points and segment the sentence as shown - understanding and assimilating the meaning of each segment bit by bit!
Sentence Structure
- A group of ecologists
- led by Axel Mithöfer at the Max Planck Institute
- for Chemical Ecology in Germany
- examined the defensive responses
- of two varieties of the sweet potato plant (?)
- TN57,
- which is known for its insect resistance,
- and TN66,
- which is much more susceptible to pests.
- TN57,
- of two varieties of the sweet potato plant (?)
Understanding the Meaning
Let's start from the beginning:
A group of ecologists did something - they:
- 'examined the defensive responses of two varieties of the sweet potato plant'
- They studied how two different types of sweet potato plants defend themselves
This is where we have the blank - right after 'plant.'
Let's look at the choices:
- We're deciding what punctuation (if any) should come after 'plant'
- A period, semicolon, nothing, or colon
To see what works here, let's read what comes next and understand what it's saying!
After the blank, we get:
- 'TN57, which is known for its insect resistance, and TN66, which is much more susceptible to pests.'
Now let's understand what this is telling us:
- 'TN57, which is known for its insect resistance'
- This is naming the first variety
- It adds the detail that TN57 is resistant to insects
- 'and TN66, which is much more susceptible to pests'
- This is naming the second variety
- It adds the detail that TN66 is NOT resistant - pests can attack it easily
So the complete picture is:
- The sentence mentions 'two varieties of the sweet potato plant'
- Then it names exactly what those two varieties ARE: TN57 and TN66
What do we notice about the structure here?
- The sentence makes a general statement: 'two varieties of the sweet potato plant'
- Then it gives us the SPECIFIC list of what those varieties are
- What comes after the blank is a list that specifies/names the two varieties
- It's not a complete sentence on its own
- It's providing the specific examples of what was just mentioned
This is a classic list-introduction situation. When you mention something general and then provide the specific list or names, you use a colon to introduce that list.
The correct answer is D (plant:)
Grammar Concept Applied
Using a Colon to Introduce a List or Specification
When your sentence mentions something in a general way and then provides the specific examples or list of what that thing is, use a colon to introduce the specification (this punctuation mark is called a colon in grammar terms):
Pattern:
- General statement: The team studied three methods
- Colon introduces list: The team studied three methods: filtration, distillation, and evaporation
- Before colon = complete thought mentioning 'three methods'
- After colon = specific list naming what those methods are
Another example:
- General statement: The museum features art from two periods
- Colon introduces specification: The museum features art from two periods: the Renaissance and the Baroque
- Before colon = complete thought mentioning 'two periods'
- After colon = names exactly which two periods
In this question:
- Before colon: 'examined the defensive responses of two varieties of the sweet potato plant'
- Complete thought mentioning 'two varieties'
- After colon: 'TN57, which is known for its insect resistance, and TN66, which is much more susceptible to pests'
- Specifies which two varieties
The colon signals: 'Here comes the specific information about what I just mentioned.'
plant.
✗ Incorrect
- A period would end the sentence completely
- But 'TN57, which is known for its insect resistance, and TN66, which is much more susceptible to pests' cannot stand alone as a sentence
- It's just a list of nouns with describing phrases - a fragment
- This creates a sentence fragment error
plant;
✗ Incorrect
- A semicolon connects two complete thoughts that could each stand as separate sentences
- What comes after the blank is NOT a complete thought - it's a list of noun phrases
- 'TN57... and TN66...' cannot stand alone as a sentence
- This misuses the semicolon
plant
✗ Incorrect
- With no punctuation, the sentence would read 'plant TN57...'
- This doesn't properly signal the relationship between the general statement (two varieties) and the specific list (TN57 and TN66)
- The structure becomes unclear and grammatically awkward
- Proper punctuation is needed to mark this shift from general to specific
plant:
✓ Correct
- Correct as explained in the solution above.