A marsupial commonly called the Tasmanian devil, ______
GMAT Standard English Conventions : (Grammar) Questions
A marsupial commonly called the Tasmanian devil, ______
Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?
distinctive Australian carnivores include this species, Sarcophilus harrisii, found only on the island of Tasmania.
the island of Tasmania is home to Sarcophilus harrisii, known for its powerful bite and stocky build.
Sarcophilus harrisii is native to Tasmania and recognized for its powerful bite and nocturnal hunting behavior.
powerful jaws and aggressive feeding behavior characterize Sarcophilus harrisii, Tasmania's largest carnivorous marsupial.
Sentence Structure
- A marsupial commonly called the Tasmanian devil,
- [?]
Understanding the Meaning
Let's start reading from the beginning:
- 'A marsupial commonly called the Tasmanian devil,'
- This is introducing us to a specific marsupial
- We call it the Tasmanian devil
- The comma at the end signals that more is coming
Now here's where we need to fill in the blank. This opening phrase is describing a marsupial, so let's look at what our choices want to put next.
Let's check what comes right after the comma in each choice:
- Choice A starts with: "distinctive Australian carnivores"
- That's a general category of animals (plural)
- Choice B starts with: "the island of Tasmania"
- That's a place, not an animal
- Choice C starts with: "Sarcophilus harrisii"
- That's a scientific name for a specific animal
- Choice D starts with: "powerful jaws and aggressive feeding behavior"
- Those are characteristics or features
What do we notice about the structure here?
- The opening phrase "A marsupial commonly called the Tasmanian devil" is describing something
- It's waiting to tell us what this marsupial IS
- Whatever comes right after the comma needs to BE that marsupial
- Think of it like this:
- If I say "A student known for her math skills," and then pause
- The next thing I say should be the actual student - like "Sarah"
- Not "the school" or "good grades" or "students"
So we need the actual marsupial to come right after that comma.
The correct answer is Choice C: "Sarcophilus harrisii" is the scientific name for this specific marsupial. It's the thing being described by the opening phrase.
The complete sentence reads:
- "A marsupial commonly called the Tasmanian devil, Sarcophilus harrisii is native to Tasmania and recognized for its powerful bite and nocturnal hunting behavior."
- The opening tells us what Sarcophilus harrisii is called
- Then the main part tells us where it lives and what it's known for
Grammar Concept Applied
Introductory Descriptive Phrases: What They Must Connect To
When you start a sentence with a descriptive phrase followed by a comma, the thing being described must come immediately after that comma (this creates what's called a modifier relationship in grammar terms).
Here's the pattern:
Incorrect (misplaced):
- A student known for her brilliant writing, the essay contest attracted many applicants.
- "A student" can't be describing "the essay contest"
- The opening describes a student, but no student appears after the comma
Correct:
- A student known for her brilliant writing, Maria won the essay contest.
- "A student" correctly describes "Maria"
- Maria (the actual student) comes right after the comma
In this question:
- Opening phrase: "A marsupial commonly called the Tasmanian devil"
- This describes a specific marsupial
- What must follow: The actual marsupial = Sarcophilus harrisii
- Why it works: The opening phrase logically connects to and describes what comes next
Quick test: Read the opening phrase and ask "What is this describing?" Whatever answer you get must be what comes after the comma.
distinctive Australian carnivores include this species, Sarcophilus harrisii, found only on the island of Tasmania.
- This puts "distinctive Australian carnivores" right after the opening phrase
- This would make it seem like "A marsupial commonly called the Tasmanian devil" is describing "carnivores" (plural, general)
- But the opening describes ONE specific marsupial, not a group of carnivores
- This creates a misplaced modifier error - the opening phrase doesn't logically connect to what follows it
the island of Tasmania is home to Sarcophilus harrisii, known for its powerful bite and stocky build.
- This puts "the island of Tasmania" right after the opening phrase
- This would make it seem like "A marsupial commonly called the Tasmanian devil" is describing Tasmania
- But Tasmania is a place, not a marsupial
- Clear misplaced modifier - the opening can't be describing an island
Sarcophilus harrisii is native to Tasmania and recognized for its powerful bite and nocturnal hunting behavior.
Correct as explained in the solution above.
powerful jaws and aggressive feeding behavior characterize Sarcophilus harrisii, Tasmania's largest carnivorous marsupial.
- This puts "powerful jaws and aggressive feeding behavior" right after the opening phrase
- This would make it seem like "A marsupial commonly called the Tasmanian devil" is describing these characteristics
- But jaws and behavior are features, not the marsupial itself
- Another misplaced modifier - the opening needs to describe the animal, not its features