A study published by Rice University geoscientist Ming Tang in 2019 offers a new explanation for the origin of Earth's...
GMAT Standard English Conventions : (Grammar) Questions
A study published by Rice University geoscientist Ming Tang in 2019 offers a new explanation for the origin of Earth's _______ structures called arcs, towering ridges that form when a dense oceanic plate subducts under a less dense continental plate, melts in the mantle below, and then rises and bursts through the continental crust above.
Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?
continents geological
continents: geological
continents; geological
continents. Geological
Let's begin by understanding the meaning of this sentence. We'll use our understanding of pause points and segment the sentence as shown - understanding and assimilating the meaning of each segment bit by bit!
Sentence Structure
- A study published by Rice University geoscientist Ming Tang in 2019
- offers a new explanation
- for the origin of Earth's continents (?) geological structures called arcs,
- towering ridges that form
- when a dense oceanic plate subducts under a less dense continental plate,
- melts in the mantle below,
- and then rises and bursts through the continental crust above.
- when a dense oceanic plate subducts under a less dense continental plate,
- towering ridges that form
- for the origin of Earth's continents (?) geological structures called arcs,
- offers a new explanation
Understanding the Meaning
Let's start reading from the beginning:
- A study published by Rice University geoscientist Ming Tang in 2019
- offers a new explanation
- for the origin of Earth's continents...
This is where we have the blank. Let's look at the choices:
- Choice A: continents geological (no punctuation)
- Choice B: continents: geological (colon)
- Choice C: continents; geological (semicolon)
- Choice D: continents. Geological (period, new sentence)
To see what works here, let's read the rest of the sentence and understand what it's saying!
The sentence continues: "geological structures called arcs, towering ridges that form when a dense oceanic plate subducts under a less dense continental plate, melts in the mantle below, and then rises and bursts through the continental crust above."
Now let's understand what this is telling us:
- "Geological structures called arcs"
- These are specific geological features
- They're called "arcs"
- "Towering ridges that form when..."
- This describes what arcs are and how they form
- The formation process involves plate tectonics - one plate going under another, melting, then rising back up
So the complete picture is:
- The study explains the origin of something specific about Earth's continents
- That "something" is: geological structures called arcs
- These arcs are towering ridges formed by plate tectonics
What do we notice about the structure here?
- Before the blank: "the origin of Earth's continents"
- This is part of a complete thought (the whole clause starting with "A study... offers a new explanation for...")
- After the blank: "geological structures called arcs, towering ridges..."
- This is NOT a complete sentence
- It's a noun phrase ("geological structures") with descriptors
- No main verb for this phrase
The relationship:
- "Geological structures called arcs" is specifying what aspect of Earth's continents the study is about
- It's like saying: "the origin of Earth's continents - specifically, these geological structures called arcs"
A colon is perfect for this because:
- A colon can follow a complete thought
- A colon introduces a specification or explanation
- The material after the colon doesn't need to be a complete sentence
So we need Choice B: continents: geological - the colon introduces specific information about what aspect of continents the study explains.
GRAMMAR CONCEPT APPLIED
Using Colons to Introduce Specifications
A colon can follow a complete thought and introduce material that explains, specifies, or elaborates on what came before. The material after the colon doesn't need to be a complete sentence - it can be a word, phrase, or list.
Pattern: Complete thought + colon + specification/explanation
Example 1:
- "The research focused on one critical factor: temperature"
- Before colon: complete thought
- After colon: a single noun specifying what factor
Example 2:
- "The museum features artifacts from several periods: ancient pottery, medieval weapons, and Renaissance paintings"
- Before colon: complete thought
- After colon: a list (not a complete sentence)
Example 3 (our question):
- "A new explanation for the origin of Earth's continents: geological structures called arcs"
- Before colon: complete thought (as part of the full clause)
- After colon: noun phrase specifying what aspect of continents
Key distinction:
- A semicolon requires independent clauses on both sides
- A colon requires only a complete thought before it; what follows can be explanatory material that isn't a complete sentence
- In this question, what follows is just a noun phrase with modifiers, so a colon works but a semicolon doesn't
continents geological
✗ Incorrect
- Creates a grammatical error by placing two nouns directly together without proper punctuation
- "Continents geological structures" is not standard English construction
- You cannot have "continents" followed immediately by "geological" without punctuation or a possessive form
continents: geological
✓ Correct
- Correct as explained in the solution above.
continents; geological
✗ Incorrect
- A semicolon requires an independent clause (a complete sentence) on both sides
- What follows would be: "Geological structures called arcs, towering ridges that form..."
- This is just a noun phrase with modifiers - it has no main verb
- This creates a sentence fragment after the semicolon
continents. Geological
✗ Incorrect
- A period creates two separate sentences
- The second "sentence" would be: "Geological structures called arcs, towering ridges that form when..."
- This is not a complete sentence - it lacks a main verb for "geological structures"
- This creates a fragment, not a complete sentence