According to the traditional RYB (red-yellow-blue) color model, yellow is a complementary color to purple. However, yellow ________ considered complem...
GMAT Standard English Conventions : (Grammar) Questions
According to the traditional RYB (red-yellow-blue) color model, yellow is a complementary color to purple. However, yellow ________ considered complementary to blue in modern color theory.
Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?
is
having been
to be
being
Sentence Structure
- According to the traditional RYB (red-yellow-blue) color model,
- yellow
- is a complementary color to purple.
- yellow
- However,
- yellow
- [?] considered complementary to blue
- in modern color theory.
- [?] considered complementary to blue
- yellow
Understanding the Meaning
The first sentence tells us about traditional color theory:
- 'According to the traditional RYB (red-yellow-blue) color model'
- Sets up that we're talking about an older way of thinking about colors
- 'yellow is a complementary color to purple'
- In this traditional model, yellow and purple are opposites/complements
Now the second sentence starts with a contrast:
- 'However, yellow...'
- This signals we're about to hear something different
This is where we have the blank. Let's look at the choices:
- is
- having been
- to be
- being
To see what works here, let's read the rest of the sentence:
- 'yellow ______ considered complementary to blue in modern color theory'
What do we notice about the structure here?
- The word 'considered' is sitting right after our blank
- 'Considered' needs a helping verb before it to make a complete verb phrase
- This is describing what happens to yellow - yellow receives the action of being considered
- So we need: helping verb + 'considered'
- In the present tense, when something receives an action, we use: 'is' + past participle
- Here: 'is' + 'considered' = 'is considered'
The correct answer is Choice A: is
This creates: 'yellow is considered complementary to blue in modern color theory'
- A complete verb phrase
- Shows the contrast: traditional model says yellow complements purple, but modern theory says yellow complements blue
GRAMMAR CONCEPT APPLIED
Completing Passive Voice Verb Phrases
When the subject of a sentence receives an action rather than performing it (called passive voice in grammar terms), you need a complete verb phrase made of two parts:
Form of "to be" + Past Participle
Examples:
- The report is written by the team (present tense)
- The results were analyzed carefully (past tense)
- The theory is considered valid (present tense)
In our question:
- Subject: "yellow"
- Past participle waiting for help: "considered"
- Present tense form of "to be": "is"
- Complete phrase: "yellow is considered complementary to blue"
Why only "is" works:
- "is" + "considered" = complete passive voice verb phrase ✓
- "having been considered" = incomplete participle phrase ✗
- "to be considered" = infinitive, not a complete verb ✗
- "being considered" = incomplete participle phrase ✗
A sentence needs a complete verb phrase as its backbone. In passive voice constructions with a past participle like "considered," you must include a form of "to be" to create that complete phrase.
is
- Correct as explained in the solution above.
having been
- "yellow having been considered" doesn't create a complete verb phrase for the main sentence
- "Having been" is a participle form that would need to be describing something, but here we need the main verb
- This creates a sentence fragment
to be
- "yellow to be considered" is not a complete verb phrase
- "To be" is an infinitive form that cannot serve as the main verb of a sentence
- This creates a sentence fragment
being
- "yellow being considered" doesn't give us a complete main verb
- "Being" by itself is a participle form that needs a helping verb, or it would create a fragment
- This creates a sentence fragment