After the printing press was introduced in 1440, handwritten manuscripts from Europe's medieval period were often destroyed and the paper...
GMAT Standard English Conventions : (Grammar) Questions
After the printing press was introduced in 1440, handwritten manuscripts from Europe's medieval period were often destroyed and the paper used for other purposes. In one instance, pages ______ a collection of Norse tales dating to 1270 were discovered lining a bishop's miter (hat).
Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?
from:
from,
from
from—
Let's begin by understanding the meaning of this sentence. We'll use our understanding of pause points and segment the sentence as shown - understanding and assimilating the meaning of each segment bit by bit!
Sentence Structure
Sentence 1:
- After the printing press was introduced in 1440,
- handwritten manuscripts
- from Europe's medieval period
and the paper used for other purposes.
Sentence 2:
- In one instance,
- pages
- from [?]
- a collection of Norse tales
- dating to 1270
- lining a bishop's miter (hat).
Understanding the Meaning
Let's start with the first sentence to understand the context:
"After the printing press was introduced in 1440, handwritten manuscripts from Europe's medieval period were often destroyed and the paper used for other purposes."
This tells us:
- Once printing presses arrived, old handwritten manuscripts weren't valued
- These manuscripts were often destroyed and their paper recycled
Now let's move to the second sentence where we have the blank:
"In one instance, pages ______ a collection of Norse tales dating to 1270 were discovered lining a bishop's miter (hat)."
This is where we have the blank. Let's look at the choices:
- They all have the word "from"
- But they differ in what comes after: colon, comma, nothing, or dash
To see what works here, let's read the full sentence and understand what it's saying!
The sentence structure is:
- Subject: "pages"
- Then we have: "from a collection of Norse tales dating to 1270"
- Main verb: "were discovered"
- Where/how: "lining a bishop's miter"
So the complete picture is:
- Pages (from a certain collection) were discovered being used as hat lining
- Specifically, these pages came from a collection of Norse tales from 1270
What do we notice about the structure here?
The phrase "from a collection of Norse tales dating to 1270" is describing which pages we're talking about:
- "From" is a preposition showing where the pages came from
- "a collection of Norse tales dating to 1270" is what follows the preposition - it's the object of the preposition
- Together, they form a prepositional phrase: "from a collection..."
This is a key grammatical relationship:
- A preposition and its object work together as a tight unit
- They connect directly without any punctuation between them
- The preposition "from" needs to flow right into "a collection"
So we need: from with no punctuation following it - Choice C.
The phrase flows naturally: "pages from a collection of Norse tales..."
GRAMMAR CONCEPT APPLIED
Prepositions Connect Directly to Their Objects
When you use a preposition (like "from," "to," "in," "with," "about"), it must connect directly to what follows it - its object - without any punctuation in between. A preposition and its object form a grammatical unit (called a prepositional phrase in grammar terms).
The pattern:
- Preposition + Object (no punctuation between them)
Examples:
- ✓ "The letter from my grandmother arrived yesterday"
- from = preposition
- my grandmother = object
- No punctuation between them
- ✗ "The letter from: my grandmother arrived yesterday"
- Incorrect - colon breaks the preposition-object connection
- ✓ "We talked about the incident for hours"
- about = preposition
- the incident = object
- No punctuation between them
In this question:
- Preposition: "from"
- Object: "a collection of Norse tales dating to 1270"
- They must connect directly: "pages from a collection of Norse tales..."
Any punctuation after "from" would incorrectly break this grammatical unit.
from:
✗ Incorrect
- A colon cannot come between a preposition and its object
- Colons are used to introduce explanations or lists, but the preposition "from" already shows the relationship we need
- This breaks the natural grammatical structure of the prepositional phrase
from,
✗ Incorrect
- A comma cannot separate a preposition from its object
- This breaks the fundamental rule that prepositions and their objects must connect directly
- It creates an ungrammatical structure
from
✓ Correct
Correct as explained in the solution above.
from—
✗ Incorrect
- A dash, like a comma, incorrectly separates the preposition from its object
- Dashes suggest an interruption or emphasis, which doesn't fit the straightforward descriptive relationship here
- This also creates an ungrammatical structure