All samples from last week's production run, which lasted seventy-two consecutive hours, _____ examined by quality control specialists.
GMAT Standard English Conventions : (Grammar) Questions
All samples from last week's production run, which lasted seventy-two consecutive hours, _____ examined by quality control specialists.
Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?
was
have been
are
were
Let's begin by understanding the meaning of this sentence. We'll use our understanding of pause points and segment the sentence as shown - understanding and assimilating the meaning of each segment bit by bit!
Sentence Structure
- All samples from last week's production run,
- which lasted seventy-two consecutive hours,
- [?] examined by quality control specialists.
Understanding the Meaning
Let me start reading from the beginning to understand what this sentence is saying.
'All samples from last week's production run'
- This tells us the subject - we're talking about samples
- Specifically, samples from a production run that happened last week
- 'All samples' - this is a plural subject (more than one sample)
'which lasted seventy-two consecutive hours'
- This gives us extra information about that production run
- It tells us how long it lasted - 72 hours straight
- Notice 'lasted' is past tense - this already happened
Now here's where we need to fill in the blank:
- 'All samples... ______ examined by quality control specialists'
Let's look at our choices:
- They're all forms of helping verbs that would work with 'examined'
- We're choosing between:
- was (singular, past)
- have been (plural, present perfect)
- are (plural, present)
- were (plural, past)
Based on what I've read so far, what do I need?
For agreement (matching the subject):
- My subject is 'All samples' - that's PLURAL
- So I need a plural verb
- This rules out 'was' (singular)
For tense (matching the time frame):
- 'last week's production run' - clearly in the past
- 'which lasted' - past tense confirms this happened in the past
- So I need a past tense verb
- This rules out 'are' (present) and 'have been' (present perfect)
So we need were - it's plural (matches 'samples') and past tense (matches 'last week's' and 'lasted').
The complete sentence tells us: All the samples from last week's production run (which went on for 72 consecutive hours) were examined by quality control specialists.
GRAMMAR CONCEPT APPLIED
Subject-Verb Agreement with Tense Consistency
When choosing the correct verb form, you need to check TWO things:
1. NUMBER AGREEMENT - Does the verb match the subject?
- Identify the true subject (the main noun doing or receiving the action)
- Don't be distracted by words in descriptive phrases
- Match your verb to whether the subject is singular or plural
In this sentence:
- Subject: "All samples" (plural)
- Not "production run" (that's in a descriptive phrase)
- Need: plural verb (were, not was)
2. TENSE CONSISTENCY - Does the verb match the time frame?
- Look for time markers (like "last week's," "yesterday," "currently")
- Look at other verbs in the sentence
- Keep your tenses consistent with the established time frame
In this sentence:
- Time marker: "last week's production run" (past)
- Other verb: "lasted" (past tense)
- Need: past tense verb (were, not are or have been)
Why both matter here:
- "All samples... were examined" ✓ (plural + past)
- "All samples... was examined" ✗ (singular + past) - number error
- "All samples... are examined" ✗ (plural + present) - tense error
- "All samples... have been examined" ✗ (plural + present perfect) - tense error
was
✗ Incorrect
- Creates a subject-verb agreement error
- "was" is singular, but our subject "All samples" is plural
- You can't say "All samples was examined" - it should be "were examined"
have been
✗ Incorrect
- Creates a tense inconsistency
- "have been" is present perfect tense, which connects past actions to the present
- But the context makes clear this is about a completed past event ("last week's production run," "which lasted")
- The simple past "were" is needed for a completed past action
are
✗ Incorrect
- Creates a tense error
- "are" is present tense, but the time markers tell us this happened in the past
- "last week's production run" and "lasted" establish a past time frame
- Using present tense "are" contradicts the past context
were
✓ Correct
Correct as explained in the solution above.