prismlearning.academy Logo
NEUR
N

Although migrations of the monarch butterfly _____ thousands of miles, individual butterflies typically complete only one leg of the entire...

GMAT Standard English Conventions : (Grammar) Questions

Source: Prism
Standard English Conventions
Form, Structure, and Sense
MEDIUM
...
...
Notes
Post a Query

Although migrations of the monarch butterfly _____ thousands of miles, individual butterflies typically complete only one leg of the entire journey.

Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?

A

spans

B

is spanning

C

span

D

has spanned

Solution

Let's begin by understanding the meaning of this sentence. We'll use our understanding of pause points and segment the sentence as shown - understanding and assimilating the meaning of each segment bit by bit!

Sentence Structure

  • Although migrations of the monarch butterfly
  • [?] thousands of miles,
  • individual butterflies typically complete only one leg of the entire journey.

Understanding the Meaning

Let's start reading from the beginning:

'Although migrations of the monarch butterfly...'

Now here's where we need to fill in the blank:

  • 'migrations of the monarch butterfly _____ thousands of miles'

Let's look at our choices:

  • A. spans (singular)
  • B. is spanning (singular)
  • C. span (plural)
  • D. has spanned (singular)

What do we notice about the structure here?

  • The subject of this part is 'migrations' - that's the thing doing the action
    • 'migrations' is plural
  • 'of the monarch butterfly' is just a descriptive phrase
    • It tells us WHICH migrations we're talking about
    • But it's not the subject itself
  • The word 'butterfly' appears right before the blank
    • This might tempt us to use a singular verb
    • BUT 'butterfly' is not the subject - it's part of the descriptive phrase
  • The verb needs to match 'migrations' (plural), not 'butterfly' (singular)

So we need: span - the plural form that agrees with 'migrations.'

Now let's read the rest to see the complete picture:

'individual butterflies typically complete only one leg of the entire journey.'

This is creating an interesting contrast:

  • The migrations themselves span thousands of miles (the whole journey is huge)
  • BUT each individual butterfly only completes one portion of that journey
  • So even though the migration as a whole covers thousands of miles, no single butterfly makes the entire trip

The correct answer is C: span


Grammar Concept Applied

Making Verbs Agree with Subjects When There's a Phrase In Between

When a descriptive phrase comes between the subject and verb, you need to identify the true subject and make sure the verb agrees with it - not with a word in the phrase that happens to be closer to the verb.

The pattern:

  • Subject + descriptive phrase + Verb
  • The verb must agree with the subject, even if other nouns appear in between

Example 1:

  • "The box of chocolates are on the table."
  • "The box of chocolates is on the table."
  • Subject: "box" (singular)
  • Descriptive phrase: "of chocolates"
  • Verb must match "box": is (singular)

Example 2:

  • "The students in the classroom works quietly."
  • "The students in the classroom work quietly."
  • Subject: "students" (plural)
  • Descriptive phrase: "in the classroom"
  • Verb must match "students": work (plural)

In our question:

  • Subject: "migrations" (plural)
  • Descriptive phrase: "of the monarch butterfly" (contains singular "butterfly")
  • The verb must match "migrations": span (plural)
  • Even though "butterfly" is singular and appears right before the verb, it's not the subject

The key is to ask yourself: "What is actually doing the action?" In this sentence, what's spanning thousands of miles? The migrations - plural. So we need the plural verb "span."

Answer Choices Explained
A

spans

✗ Incorrect

  • This is a singular verb, but our subject 'migrations' is plural
  • Students might be tempted by this because 'butterfly' (singular) appears right before the blank
  • But 'butterfly' is not the subject - it's part of the phrase describing the migrations
  • This creates a subject-verb agreement error
B

is spanning

✗ Incorrect

  • This is also singular, so it doesn't agree with the plural subject 'migrations'
  • Additionally, the present continuous tense ('is spanning') is wrong here
  • We're describing a general fact about these migrations, not an action happening right now
  • Creates both an agreement error and a tense error
C

span

✓ Correct

  • Correct as explained in the solution above.
D

has spanned

✗ Incorrect

  • This is singular, so it fails to agree with 'migrations'
  • The present perfect tense ('has spanned') is also inappropriate
  • We're stating a general, timeless fact about how far these migrations extend
  • Present perfect would suggest the spanning was completed in the past with current relevance
  • Creates both an agreement error and a tense error
Rate this Solution
Tell us what you think about this solution
...
...
Forum Discussions
Start a new discussion
Post
Load More
Similar Questions
Finding similar questions...
Previous Attempts
Loading attempts...
Similar Questions
Finding similar questions...
Parallel Question Generator
Create AI-generated questions with similar patterns to master this question type.