Author Madeline L'Engle, ______ to create a suspenseful tone that draws the reader in, begins her novel A Wrinkle in...
GMAT Standard English Conventions : (Grammar) Questions
Author Madeline L'Engle, ______ to create a suspenseful tone that draws the reader in, begins her novel A Wrinkle in Time with descriptions of 'wraithlike shadows' and 'the frenzied lashing of the wind.'
Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?
looked
looks
is looking
looking
Let's begin by understanding the meaning of this sentence. We'll use our understanding of pause points and segment the sentence as shown - understanding and assimilating the meaning of each segment bit by bit!
Sentence Structure
- Author Madeline L'Engle,
- [?] to create a suspenseful tone
- that draws the reader in,
- begins her novel A Wrinkle in Time
- with descriptions of 'wraithlike shadows'
- and 'the frenzied lashing of the wind.'
- with descriptions of 'wraithlike shadows'
Understanding the Meaning
Let's start reading from the beginning:
The sentence is about:
- 'Author Madeline L'Engle'
This is where we have the blank:
- 'Author Madeline L'Engle, ______ to create a suspenseful tone that draws the reader in'
Let's look at the choices:
- looked
- looks
- is looking
- looking
These are all different forms of the same verb. To see what works here, let's read the rest of the sentence and understand what it's saying!
The sentence continues:
- 'begins her novel A Wrinkle in Time with descriptions of 'wraithlike shadows' and 'the frenzied lashing of the wind.''
So the complete sentence is telling us:
- L'Engle begins her novel with these dark, dramatic descriptions
- The reason or purpose for doing this is to create a suspenseful tone
Now, what do we notice about the structure here?
- 'begins' is the main action of the sentence
- This is what the sentence is fundamentally telling us: L'Engle begins her novel in a certain way
- The phrase with the blank ('[verb form] to create a suspenseful tone...')
- sits between commas
- provides extra information about her intention or purpose
- is NOT the main action - it's describing WHY she begins the novel this way
- Since 'begins' is already doing the job of the main verb, we need something else for the blank
- We can't have another complete verb form here competing with 'begins'
- We need a form that provides descriptive or background information
So we need: looking
This creates a descriptive phrase 'looking to create a suspenseful tone...' that tells us her goal or intention, working alongside the main action 'begins.'
GRAMMAR CONCEPT APPLIED
Using Descriptive Verb Forms vs. Main Verbs
In a sentence, you have one main verb that expresses the primary action. When you want to add extra information about purpose, intention, or background action, you use a participial form (the "-ing" form, called a present participle in grammar terms) rather than a complete verb form.
Pattern:
- Main verb structure: Subject + main verb + rest of sentence
- Example: "The author begins her novel with dramatic descriptions"
- Adding descriptive information with participle: Subject + participial phrase (set off by commas) + main verb + rest
- Example: "The author, looking to create suspense, begins her novel with dramatic descriptions"
- "looking to create suspense" = descriptive phrase providing background/purpose
- "begins" = main verb (the primary action)
In our sentence:
- Subject: "Author Madeline L'Engle"
- Descriptive phrase: "looking to create a suspenseful tone that draws the reader in" (her intention)
- Main verb: "begins" (the primary action)
- The participial form "looking" allows the phrase to provide supplementary information without competing with the main verb
Why not finite verbs (looked, looks, is looking)?
- These are complete verb forms that assert independent actions
- They would create structural confusion by competing with "begins"
- The sentence needs descriptive information, not multiple competing actions
looked
✗ Incorrect
- This is a complete past tense verb that would create a second main action
- The sentence would be trying to have two competing main verbs without proper connection: "looked to create" and "begins"
- This creates a grammatical clash
looks
✗ Incorrect
- This is a complete present tense verb
- Same problem - it creates another complete verb phrase that competes with "begins" as the main verb
- You can't have two main verbs in this structure without coordination
is looking
✗ Incorrect
- This is a complete progressive verb form
- It has the same issue - it's a full verb phrase that would clash with "begins"
- The sentence needs descriptive information, not another complete action
looking
✓ Correct
Correct as explained in the solution above.