Ben Cohen and Jerry Greenfield opened their first ice cream shop in Burlington, Vermont, in 1978. The business started in...
GMAT Standard English Conventions : (Grammar) Questions
Ben Cohen and Jerry Greenfield opened their first ice cream shop in Burlington, Vermont, in 1978. The business started in a renovated gas station with just twelve flavors. _____ expanded their company into an international brand known for creative flavors and social activism.
Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?
Each
Both
He
It
Let's begin by understanding the meaning of this sentence. We'll use our understanding of pause points and segment the sentence as shown - understanding and assimilating the meaning of each segment bit by bit!
Sentence Structure
Sentence 1:
- Ben Cohen and Jerry Greenfield
opened their first ice cream shop in Burlington, Vermont, in 1978.
Sentence 2:
- The business
started in a renovated gas station with just twelve flavors.
Sentence 3 (with blank):
- [?]
expanded their company into an international brand
known for creative flavors and social activism.
Understanding the Meaning
Let's start from the beginning:
"Ben Cohen and Jerry Greenfield opened their first ice cream shop in Burlington, Vermont, in 1978."
- Two people - Ben Cohen and Jerry Greenfield - started this business together
- They opened an ice cream shop
- The word "their" tells us they jointly owned it
"The business started in a renovated gas station with just twelve flavors."
- We learn some background about how the business began
- It was in a renovated gas station
- They started small - just twelve flavors
Now we reach the blank:
"_____ expanded their company into an international brand known for creative flavors and social activism."
This is where we need to fill in the blank. Let's look at our choices:
- Each, Both, He, It
To see what works here, let's read the rest of the sentence and understand what it's saying!
The complete sentence would be:
- "[Something] expanded their company into an international brand..."
Now let's understand the key parts:
- "expanded their company"
- Someone/something made the company grow bigger
- But notice: "THEIR company"
- "Their" is plural - it refers to Ben and Jerry together
- "into an international brand"
- The company became known worldwide
- It grew from a small local shop to something international
What do we notice?
- The word "their" is the crucial clue here
- "Their" is plural
- It refers back to Ben Cohen and Jerry Greenfield
- These are the only two people mentioned in the passage
- So the subject of this sentence (the blank) must:
- Refer to both Ben and Jerry
- Be plural to match with "their"
- Make logical sense - who expanded "their" company? The two founders.
The correct answer is Both - it's the only plural pronoun that clearly refers to the two founders and matches with "their company."
GRAMMAR CONCEPT APPLIED
Matching Pronouns with Their Antecedents
When you use a pronoun, it must match what it refers to (called the antecedent in grammar terms) in number (singular or plural) and make logical sense in context. You also need to make sure all pronouns in the sentence are consistent with each other.
The Pattern:
Step 1: Identify who or what the pronoun refers to
- In this passage: "Ben Cohen and Jerry Greenfield" (two people = plural)
Step 2: Check if other pronouns in the sentence give you clues
- "their company" uses the plural possessive "their"
- This confirms we need a plural subject
Step 3: Choose the pronoun that matches
- Need: plural pronoun for two people
- Answer: "Both" ✓
Example from our question:
- Antecedent: "Ben Cohen and Jerry Greenfield" (two people)
- Pronoun needed: must be plural
- Later in sentence: "their company" (plural possessive)
- Correct choice: "Both" (plural, refers to two people)
- Result: "Both expanded their company..." ✓
Why this matters on the SAT:
The test often includes a possessive pronoun (like "their," "his," "its") later in the sentence as a clue. Make sure your subject pronoun matches in number with any other pronouns in the same sentence.
Each
✗ Incorrect
- "Each" is grammatically singular, even though it refers to multiple people considered one at a time
- It would create a mismatch: "Each expanded their company" - singular subject with plural possessive
- Also, "each" suggests they expanded the company separately/individually, which doesn't make logical sense for business partners who built something together
Both
✓ Correct
Correct as explained in the solution above.
He
✗ Incorrect
- "He" is singular and would refer to only one person
- But we have two founders - which one would "he" refer to? It's unclear
- "He" wouldn't match with "their company" - it would need to be "his company"
- Creates both a pronoun agreement error and an ambiguous reference
It
✗ Incorrect
- "It" would most naturally refer to "the business" from the previous sentence
- But then we'd have "it expanded their company" - the business expanded their company?
- The business IS their company, so this creates a logical redundancy
- If "it" were the subject, we'd expect "its company" not "their company"