Biologists have discovered that the mimic octopus (Thaumoctopus mimicus) possesses a remarkable defensive adaptation. When threatened by predators, th...
GMAT Standard English Conventions : (Grammar) Questions
Biologists have discovered that the mimic octopus (Thaumoctopus mimicus) possesses a remarkable defensive adaptation. When threatened by predators, this cephalopod can alter its body shape and coloration, effectively camouflaging _____ to resemble more dangerous marine animals such as lionfish or sea snakes.
Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?
itself
themselves
them
it
Let's begin by understanding the meaning of this sentence. We'll use our understanding of pause points and segment the sentence as shown - understanding and assimilating the meaning of each segment bit by bit!
Sentence Structure
Sentence 1:
- Biologists
- have discovered
- that the mimic octopus (Thaumoctopus mimicus)
- possesses a remarkable defensive adaptation.
- that the mimic octopus (Thaumoctopus mimicus)
- have discovered
Sentence 2:
- When threatened by predators,
- this cephalopod
- can alter its body shape and coloration,
- effectively camouflaging (?)
- to resemble more dangerous marine animals
- such as lionfish or sea snakes.
- to resemble more dangerous marine animals
- effectively camouflaging (?)
- can alter its body shape and coloration,
Understanding the Meaning
Let's start with the first sentence:
- "Biologists have discovered that the mimic octopus (Thaumoctopus mimicus) possesses a remarkable defensive adaptation."
- We're learning about a specific type of octopus
- It has some kind of special defense mechanism
Now the second sentence gives us the details:
- "When threatened by predators"
- This sets up the condition - when the octopus is in danger
- "this cephalopod"
- This refers back to the mimic octopus we just learned about
- "Cephalopod" is just the scientific term for this class of sea creatures
- Notice: "this cephalopod" is singular - we're talking about one creature
- "can alter its body shape and coloration"
- The octopus can change how it looks
Now here's where we need to fill in the blank:
- "effectively camouflaging _____"
Let's look at our choices:
- We're deciding between: itself, themselves, them, or it
- These are all pronouns, so we need to figure out what noun they're referring back to
What do we notice about the structure here?
- The subject doing the action is "this cephalopod" (singular)
- The action is "camouflaging" - disguising something
- But what is being camouflaged?
- The octopus is camouflaging THE OCTOPUS
- The subject and the object are the same thing
- The cephalopod is performing an action on itself
- When the subject and object are the same entity, we need a reflexive pronoun (the -self or -selves forms)
- Since "this cephalopod" is singular, we need the singular reflexive form
So we need itself - this matches our singular antecedent and shows the octopus is camouflaging its own body.
The rest of the sentence confirms this:
- "to resemble more dangerous marine animals such as lionfish or sea snakes"
- This explains the purpose - the octopus disguises itself to look like scarier creatures
Grammar Concept Applied
Using Reflexive Pronouns When Subject and Object Are the Same
When the subject of a sentence performs an action on itself (rather than on something else), we use reflexive pronouns (called reflexive because they "reflect" back to the subject):
Singular reflexive pronouns: myself, yourself, himself, herself, itself
Plural reflexive pronouns: ourselves, yourselves, themselves
The key pattern:
- Subject acts on something else: The octopus camouflages it (some other object)
- Here "it" refers to a different entity
- Subject acts on itself: The octopus camouflages itself
- Here the octopus is both the one doing the action AND the one receiving it
- We must use the reflexive form
In our question:
- Subject: "this cephalopod" (singular)
- Action: camouflaging
- Object: the same cephalopod (it's disguising its own body)
- Therefore: "camouflaging itself" ✓
Other examples:
- The cat cleaned itself after the meal. (not "cleaned it")
- The students prepared themselves for the exam. (not "prepared them")
- The mirror reflects itself in the opposite mirror. (not "reflects it")
itself
themselves
- This is a plural reflexive pronoun
- Our antecedent "this cephalopod" is singular
- This creates a number agreement error - you can't use a plural pronoun to refer to a singular noun
them
- This has two problems: First, it's plural (doesn't match the singular "cephalopod")
- Second, it's not reflexive - "them" would suggest the octopus is camouflaging some other creatures, not itself
- But the sentence makes clear the octopus is disguising its own body
it
- While this matches the singular number, it's not reflexive
- "The cephalopod camouflages it" would suggest the cephalopod is camouflaging something else
- But the meaning requires the octopus to be camouflaging itself
- When subject and object are the same, we must use the reflexive form (-self/-selves)