Excavations at the ancient Mayan site of Tikal have uncovered numerous artifacts from the Classic Period. The stone tablets describing...
GMAT Standard English Conventions : (Grammar) Questions
Excavations at the ancient Mayan site of Tikal have uncovered numerous artifacts from the Classic Period. The stone tablets describing the reign of various rulers ______ among the most significant discoveries, providing historians with detailed chronological information.
Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?
are
was
is
has been
Let's begin by understanding the meaning of this sentence. We'll use our understanding of pause points and segment the sentence as shown - understanding and assimilating the meaning of each segment bit by bit!
Sentence Structure
- Excavations at the ancient Mayan site of Tikal
- have uncovered numerous artifacts
- from the Classic Period.
- have uncovered numerous artifacts
- The stone tablets
- describing the reign of various rulers
- [?] among the most significant discoveries,
- providing historians with detailed chronological information.
Understanding the Meaning
Let's start reading from the beginning:
The first sentence tells us:
- Excavations at Tikal (an ancient Mayan site)
- have uncovered many artifacts from the Classic Period
- This sets up the context - we're learning about archaeological discoveries
Now the second sentence begins:
- 'The stone tablets describing the reign of various rulers...'
- So among all those artifacts, there are stone tablets
- These tablets describe the reigns of various rulers
Here's where we need to fill in the blank:
- 'The stone tablets ______ among the most significant discoveries'
Let's look at our choices:
- We have: are, was, is, has been
- These are all different forms of the verb 'to be'
- The difference is whether they're singular or plural
What do we notice about the subject?
- The subject here is 'The stone tablets'
- 'Tablets' is PLURAL - we're talking about multiple tablets
- The phrase 'describing the reign of various rulers' is just giving us extra information about these tablets
- But the core subject is still 'tablets' (plural)
So we need:
- A PLURAL verb to match 'tablets'
- Looking at our choices, only 'are' is plural
- The correct answer is A. are
The sentence continues:
- 'providing historians with detailed chronological information'
- This tells us WHY these tablets are so significant
- This tells us WHY these tablets are so significant
- They give historians detailed information about when things happened
GRAMMAR CONCEPT APPLIED
Subject-Verb Agreement with Intervening Phrases
When a descriptive phrase comes between the subject and verb, you need to mentally skip over that phrase to find the true subject and make sure your verb agrees with it.
The pattern looks like this:
Subject + descriptive phrase + Verb
(These must agree in number)
Example 1:
- The books on the shelf are dusty.
- Subject: "books" (plural)
- Intervening phrase: "on the shelf"
- Verb: "are" (plural) ✓
Example 2:
- The student who won all the awards is graduating.
- Subject: "student" (singular)
- Intervening phrase: "who won all the awards"
- Verb: "is" (singular) ✓
In our question:
- Subject: "The stone tablets" (plural)
- Intervening phrase: "describing the reign of various rulers"
- Verb needed: "are" (plural) ✓
The key is to identify your subject first, then make sure your verb matches it in number, even if other words come between them.
are
✓ Correct
- Correct as explained in the solution above.
was
✗ Incorrect
- This is a singular verb form that doesn't agree with the plural subject "tablets"
- Would create a subject-verb agreement error
- You'd need a plural subject like "The stone tablet" (singular) for "was" to work
is
✗ Incorrect
- This is also singular and doesn't match the plural subject "tablets"
- Same agreement problem as "was"
- Creates a grammatical mismatch between subject and verb
has been
✗ Incorrect
- This is singular ("has" is the singular form of the helping verb)
- Doesn't agree with the plural "tablets"
- Would need "have been" to work with a plural subject