Forming extensive networks via mycorrhizal association-that is, a symbiotic relationship between plants and fungi- ______
GMAT Standard English Conventions : (Grammar) Questions
Forming extensive networks via mycorrhizal association-that is, a symbiotic relationship between plants and fungi- ______
Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?
it is the entanglement of pine trees' roots and the fungus Tricholoma matsutake's fungal hyphae that makes nutrient transport possible.
the transport of nutrients is possible through the entanglement of pine trees' roots and the fungus Tricholoma matsutake's fungal hyphae.
nutrients can be transported through the entanglement of pine trees' roots and the fungus Tricholoma matsutake's fungal hyphae.
pine trees and the fungus Tricholoma matsutake can transport nutrients through their entangled tree roots and fungal hyphae.
Let's begin by understanding the meaning of this sentence. We'll use our understanding of pause points and segment the sentence as shown - understanding and assimilating the meaning of each segment bit by bit!
Sentence Structure
- Forming extensive networks via mycorrhizal association—
- that is, a symbiotic relationship between plants and fungi—
- (?)
Understanding the Meaning
Let's start reading from the beginning:
'Forming extensive networks via mycorrhizal association—'
- This is describing something that forms (creates) extensive networks
- It does this through mycorrhizal association
'—that is, a symbiotic relationship between plants and fungi—'
- This clarifies what mycorrhizal association means
- It's a symbiotic relationship (a mutually beneficial partnership) between plants and fungi
This is where we have the blank.
Let's look at the choices to see what varies:
- Choice A: "it is the entanglement... that makes nutrient transport possible"
- Choice B: "the transport of nutrients is possible..."
- Choice C: "nutrients can be transported..."
- Choice D: "pine trees and the fungus Tricholoma matsutake can transport nutrients..."
The choices give us different subjects - different actors that could follow this opening phrase.
To see what works here, let's understand what each choice is actually saying and which one makes logical sense!
What do we notice about the structure?
- The opening phrase "Forming extensive networks" is describing something—
- Whatever comes right after this phrase must be the thing that's doing the forming.
- This is how these opening descriptive phrases work: they describe the subject that comes next.
Now let's think: what can actually FORM these networks?
- Choice A puts "it is the entanglement..." after the opening phrase
- But "it" is vague, and entanglement doesn't form networks— it's a description of what the network looks like
- Choice B puts "the transport of nutrients..." after the opening phrase
- But transport (the movement of nutrients) doesn't form networks— it's what happens through networks
- Choice C puts "nutrients..." after the opening phrase
- But nutrients don't form networks— they're just what gets moved through the networks
- Choice D puts "pine trees and the fungus Tricholoma matsutake..." after the opening phrase
- YES! These are the living organisms— the actual plants and fungi that CREATE the mycorrhizal networks
- Pine trees and the fungus are the ones doing the forming
The correct answer is Choice D because pine trees and the fungus are the organisms that logically form these extensive networks. The opening phrase "Forming extensive networks" needs to describe these organisms, not the results or processes that come from the networks.
GRAMMAR CONCEPT APPLIED
Opening Descriptive Phrases Must Describe What Comes Next
When a sentence begins with a descriptive phrase (called a participial modifier in grammar terms), especially one starting with an -ing verb form, that phrase must logically describe the noun that comes immediately after it.
The Pattern:
- Opening modifier: Working late into the night,
- Must describe → the students finished their project
- "Working late" describes the students (they're the ones working)
- Opening modifier: Having won the championship,
- Must describe → the team celebrated with fans
- "Having won" describes the team (they're the ones who won)
The Error Pattern:
- Opening modifier: Working late into the night,
- Incorrectly describes → the project was completed
- The project didn't work late; the students did
In This Question:
- Opening modifier: Forming extensive networks via mycorrhizal association
- Must describe → pine trees and the fungus Tricholoma matsutake
- These organisms are the ones forming the networks
- Would incorrectly describe → nutrients / transport / entanglement
- None of these can logically "form" networks
The Key Test: Ask yourself, "Can this noun/subject logically do the action described in the opening phrase?" If not, it's a modifier error.
it is the entanglement of pine trees' roots and the fungus Tricholoma matsutake's fungal hyphae that makes nutrient transport possible.
✗ Incorrect
- Creates a modifier error—the opening phrase "Forming extensive networks" would be describing "it," but this is just a vague placeholder pronoun
- The entanglement itself doesn't form networks; the organisms (trees and fungi) form them
- The construction "it is... that makes" awkwardly distances the actual actors from the action
the transport of nutrients is possible through the entanglement of pine trees' roots and the fungus Tricholoma matsutake's fungal hyphae.
✗ Incorrect
- Creates a modifier error—"Forming extensive networks" would be describing "the transport of nutrients"
- But transport is an abstract process or result; it doesn't form networks
- This gets the logical relationship backward: organisms form networks, then transport becomes possible
nutrients can be transported through the entanglement of pine trees' roots and the fungus Tricholoma matsutake's fungal hyphae.
✗ Incorrect
- Creates a modifier error—"Forming extensive networks" would be describing "nutrients"
- But nutrients don't form networks; they're simply what gets moved through the networks
- Again, this illogically makes the transported material seem like the creator of the network
pine trees and the fungus Tricholoma matsutake can transport nutrients through their entangled tree roots and fungal hyphae.
✓ Correct
Correct as explained in the solution above.