The relationship between genomes and epigenomes reveals how cells with identical DNA develop different _____ whereas the genome in each...
GMAT Standard English Conventions : (Grammar) Questions
The relationship between genomes and epigenomes reveals how cells with identical DNA develop different _____ whereas the genome in each cell contains a complete DNA sequence, the epigenome consists of chemical compounds that determine which traits in the sequence will be expressed.
Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?
functions
functions,
functions and,
functions:
Let's begin by understanding the meaning of this sentence. We'll use our understanding of pause points and segment the sentence as shown - understanding and assimilating the meaning of each segment bit by bit!
Sentence Structure
- The relationship between genomes and epigenomes
- reveals how cells with identical DNA
- develop different functions [?]
- whereas the genome in each cell
- contains a complete DNA sequence,
- the epigenome
- consists of chemical compounds
- that determine which traits in the sequence will be expressed.
- consists of chemical compounds
- [?] = A: (nothing) | B: , | C: , and | D: :
Understanding the Meaning
The sentence starts by telling us what a certain relationship reveals:
- "The relationship between genomes and epigenomes reveals how cells with identical DNA develop different functions"
This is saying: even though cells have identical DNA, they develop different functions. Interesting! But how does this happen?
This is where we have the blank. Let's look at the choices:
- They're asking what punctuation (if any) should follow "functions"
- Options are: nothing, a comma, a comma with "and", or a colon
To see what works here, let's read the rest of the sentence and understand what it's saying!
The sentence continues:
"whereas the genome in each cell contains a complete DNA sequence, the epigenome consists of chemical compounds that determine which traits in the sequence will be expressed."
Now let's understand what this is telling us:
- "the genome in each cell contains a complete DNA sequence"
- The genome (DNA) is the same in every cell - complete and identical
- "the epigenome consists of chemical compounds that determine which traits in the sequence will be expressed"
- The epigenome acts like a controller
- It determines which parts of that identical DNA actually get used
- Different cells can express different traits from the same DNA
So the complete picture is:
- The first part says: cells with identical DNA develop different functions
- The second part explains HOW this happens: the epigenome controls which traits from that identical DNA get expressed
What do we notice about the structure here?
- Before the blank: we have a complete statement that raises a question
- "Cells with identical DNA develop different functions" - but how?
- After the blank: we have a complete statement that answers that question
- It explains the mechanism - the epigenome determines which traits are expressed
- The second part is elaborating on and explaining the first part
- It's giving us the details of how the phenomenon works
When we have one complete thought followed by another complete thought that explains or elaborates on the first, we need a colon. The colon signals: "here comes the explanation for what I just said."
So we need a colon after "functions."
The correct answer is D.
GRAMMAR CONCEPT APPLIED
Using Colons to Introduce Explanations
When you have a complete statement followed by material that explains, elaborates on, or provides details about that statement, use a colon to introduce the explanatory material. The colon signals to the reader: "what follows will clarify or expand on what I just said."
Pattern:
- Statement: [Complete thought that sets up expectation]: [Explanation or elaboration]
Example 1:
- The study revealed a surprising finding: students who took breaks every 30 minutes retained more information than those who studied continuously.
- First part: mentions a finding (creates expectation)
- After colon: explains what that finding was
Example 2:
- The coach explained his strategy: the team would focus on defense in the first half and switch to offense after halftime.
- First part: says there's a strategy (creates expectation)
- After colon: details what that strategy is
In our question:
- Cells with identical DNA develop different functions: whereas the genome in each cell contains a complete DNA sequence, the epigenome consists of chemical compounds that determine which traits in the sequence will be expressed.
- First part: states the phenomenon (cells with same DNA differ)
- After colon: explains the mechanism (epigenome controls expression)
The colon (called a colon in punctuation terms) is perfect when the second part unpacks or clarifies the first part. It creates a clear relationship between the setup and the payoff.
functions
✗ Incorrect
- Creates a run-on sentence
- You cannot connect two complete thoughts with no punctuation at all
- This violates basic sentence structure rules
functions,
✗ Incorrect
- Creates a comma splice
- A comma alone cannot connect two complete, independent statements
- This is a grammatical error
functions and,
✗ Incorrect
- While "and" can connect two complete thoughts, it creates an awkward construction here
- The word "whereas" already establishes the relationship between the ideas
- Adding "and" before "whereas" is redundant and doesn't make logical sense
- The resulting phrase "and whereas" is not standard usage
functions:
✓ Correct
Correct as explained in the solution above.