In forecasting weather events, meteorologists sometimes discuss the role of atmospheric rivers. What are atmospheric rivers, and how ______ Part...
GMAT Standard English Conventions : (Grammar) Questions
In forecasting weather events, meteorologists sometimes discuss the role of atmospheric rivers. What are atmospheric rivers, and how ______ Part of the water cycle, atmospheric rivers are narrow channels of moisture moving through the atmosphere. In certain conditions, these 'rivers' can release some of their moisture as precipitation.
Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?
do they affect our weather.
they do affect our weather.
do they affect our weather?
they do affect our weather?
Let's begin by understanding the meaning of this sentence. We'll use our understanding of pause points and segment the sentence as shown - understanding and assimilating the meaning of each segment bit by bit!
Sentence Structure
Sentence 1:
- In forecasting weather events,
- meteorologists sometimes discuss the role of atmospheric rivers.
Sentence 2:
- What are atmospheric rivers,
- and how [do they affect our weather OR they do affect our weather] [. OR ?]
Sentence 3:
- Part of the water cycle,
- atmospheric rivers are narrow channels of moisture moving through the atmosphere.
Sentence 4:
- In certain conditions,
- these 'rivers' can release some of their moisture as precipitation.
Understanding the Meaning
Let's start reading from the beginning:
The first sentence introduces the topic:
- "In forecasting weather events, meteorologists sometimes discuss the role of atmospheric rivers."
- So meteorologists talk about atmospheric rivers when predicting weather.
Now the second sentence begins:
- "What are atmospheric rivers, and how ______"
This is where we have the blank. Let's look at the choices:
- Choice A: do they affect our weather.
- Choice B: they do affect our weather.
- Choice C: do they affect our weather?
- Choice D: they do affect our weather?
What am I deciding between?
- Word order: "do they affect" (inverted) vs. "they do affect" (standard)
- Punctuation: period vs. question mark
To see what works here, I need to understand what this sentence is doing!
What do we notice about the structure?
- The sentence starts with "What are atmospheric rivers"
- This is clearly asking a question - "What are" is a question phrase
- Then it continues: "and how ______"
- The word "and" connects two related parts
- After "What are," we now have "how"
- This means we have TWO questions being asked together
- So the structure is:
- Question 1: What are atmospheric rivers
- and
- Question 2: how ______ our weather
When we ask questions that start with words like "how," what structure do we need?
- We need inverted word order - the helping verb comes before the subject
- "how DO THEY affect" (not "how they do affect")
- This is the natural pattern for questions
- And of course, questions need to end with a question mark, not a period!
So we need: do they affect our weather?
The correct answer is Choice C.
Let me verify by reading what comes next:
- "Part of the water cycle, atmospheric rivers are narrow channels of moisture moving through the atmosphere."
- This is answering the first question - telling us WHAT atmospheric rivers are
- "In certain conditions, these 'rivers' can release some of their moisture as precipitation."
- This relates to the second question - explaining HOW they affect our weather
Yes! The passage asks two questions, then provides the answers. This confirms we need proper question structure with inverted word order and a question mark.
GRAMMAR CONCEPT APPLIED
Forming Questions with Interrogative Words
When we ask questions using interrogative words (what, how, when, where, why), we need two key elements:
1. Inverted word order: The auxiliary (helping) verb comes BEFORE the subject
- Statement: They affect our weather (subject + verb)
- Question: How do they affect our weather? (interrogative word + auxiliary verb + subject + main verb)
2. Question mark at the end: All questions must end with a question mark, not a period
The pattern:
Interrogative word + auxiliary verb + subject + main verb + ?
How + do + they + affect + ?
Compound questions: When two questions are connected with "and," both parts maintain question structure:
- "What are atmospheric rivers, and how do they affect our weather?"
- First question: "What are atmospheric rivers"
- Second question: "how do they affect our weather"
- Both need: inverted word order + question mark
In this question: The sentence asks two related questions. After the interrogative word "how," we need the inverted structure "do they affect" (not "they do affect") and must end with a question mark.
do they affect our weather.
✗ Incorrect
- Has the correct inverted word order for a question ("do they affect")
- BUT ends with a period instead of a question mark
- This creates an error: questions must always end with question marks
- Since this is part of a compound question structure starting with "What are," the second part must also maintain proper question punctuation
they do affect our weather.
✗ Incorrect
- Uses standard declarative word order ("they do affect") instead of question word order
- Ends with a period instead of a question mark
- Both elements are wrong: after the interrogative word "how" in a question, we need inverted word order and a question mark
- This would create the ungrammatical: "What are atmospheric rivers, and how they do affect our weather."
do they affect our weather?
✓ Correct
Correct as explained in the solution above.
they do affect our weather?
✗ Incorrect
- Has a question mark (correct for a question)
- BUT uses standard declarative word order ("they do affect")
- Questions that begin with interrogative words like "how" require inverted structure with the auxiliary verb before the subject
- You can't say "how they do affect" - it must be "how do they affect"