In her comprehensive study, the historian examined primary sources including royal correspondence, such as letters between monarchs_____ such as ships...
GMAT Standard English Conventions : (Grammar) Questions
In her comprehensive study, the historian examined primary sources including royal correspondence, such as letters between monarchs_____ such as ships' logs and captains' journals, and archaeological evidence, such as pottery fragments and coins.
Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?
and personal diaries; maritime records,
and personal diaries, maritime records;
and personal diaries, maritime records,
and personal diaries: maritime records,
Let's begin by understanding the meaning of this sentence. We'll use our understanding of pause points and segment the sentence as shown - understanding and assimilating the meaning of each segment bit by bit!
Sentence Structure
- In her comprehensive study,
- the historian examined primary sources including
- royal correspondence,
- such as letters between monarchs and personal diaries [?]
- maritime records [?]
- such as ships' logs and captains' journals,
- and archaeological evidence,
- such as pottery fragments and coins.
- royal correspondence,
- the historian examined primary sources including
Understanding the Meaning
Let's start from the beginning:
"In her comprehensive study, the historian examined primary sources including..."
So this historian is looking at primary sources - original historical documents. The word "including" tells us examples are coming.
First example: "royal correspondence, such as letters between monarchs and personal diaries"
- "Royal correspondence" is the first category
- "Such as letters between monarchs and personal diaries" gives specific examples of what royal correspondence means
This is where we have the blank - we need to decide what punctuation comes after "personal diaries."
Let's look at the choices:
- They differ in punctuation after "personal diaries" and after "maritime records"
- To see what works here, let's read the rest of the sentence and understand what it's saying!
The sentence continues: "such as ships' logs and captains' journals, and archaeological evidence, such as pottery fragments and coins."
Now let's understand the complete structure. The historian examined three main categories of primary sources:
- Royal correspondence
- with examples: letters between monarchs and personal diaries
- Maritime records
- with examples: ships' logs and captains' journals
- Archaeological evidence
- with examples: pottery fragments and coins
What do we notice about the structure here?
- We have a list of three parallel items
- Each follows the same pattern: [main category], such as [specific examples],
- This is a straightforward list structure
In a list like this, we use commas to separate the items consistently:
- Comma after the examples for each category
- Comma after each main category name
So we need: commas in both blank positions
The correct answer is Choice C: "and personal diaries, maritime records,"
Grammar Concept Applied
Using Commas in Lists with Internal Details
When you have a list where each item contains its own internal descriptive phrases, you still use commas to separate the main items from each other. The pattern looks like this:
Basic list:
- The store sells fruits, vegetables, and grains.
List where each item has internal details:
- The store sells fruits, such as apples and oranges, vegetables, such as carrots and lettuce, and grains, such as rice and wheat.
- Main item 1: fruits, such as apples and oranges,
- Main item 2: vegetables, such as carrots and lettuce,
- Main item 3: and grains, such as rice and wheat
In our sentence:
- Main item 1: royal correspondence, such as letters between monarchs and personal diaries,
- Main item 2: maritime records, such as ships' logs and captains' journals,
- Main item 3: and archaeological evidence, such as pottery fragments and coins
The commas maintain consistent separation between list items, even though each item contains additional information. This keeps the structure clear and parallel.
and personal diaries; maritime records,
and personal diaries; maritime records,
✗ Incorrect
- The semicolon after "personal diaries" suggests a major break in the sentence
- But "maritime records" is just the second item in a parallel list alongside "royal correspondence" and "archaeological evidence"
- There's no major break here - just continuation of the list
- The semicolon is too strong for this context
and personal diaries, maritime records;
and personal diaries, maritime records;
✗ Incorrect
- The comma after "personal diaries" works correctly
- But the semicolon after "maritime records" creates an imbalance
- This makes the punctuation inconsistent - why would this item get a semicolon when the others use commas?
- It incorrectly suggests a major break before "such as ships' logs"
and personal diaries, maritime records,
✓ Correct
Correct as explained in the solution above.
and personal diaries: maritime records,
and personal diaries: maritime records,
✗ Incorrect
- The colon suggests that "maritime records" explains or elaborates on "personal diaries"
- But these are two separate categories - maritime records don't explain personal diaries
- The colon creates an incorrect logical relationship between unrelated list items