In Marisol's 1968 sculpture Mi Mama y Yo, gone are the types of pop culture references that made the Parisian-born...
GMAT Standard English Conventions : (Grammar) Questions
In Marisol's 1968 sculpture Mi Mama y Yo, gone are the types of pop culture references that made the Parisian-born Venezuelan American artist a star at the height of the pop art movement. In ______ place is a far more personal subject: a sculptural depiction of the artist as a young girl with her mother.
Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?
its
they're
their
it's
Let's begin by understanding the meaning of this sentence. We'll use our understanding of pause points and segment the sentence as shown - understanding and assimilating the meaning of each segment bit by bit!
Sentence Structure
Sentence 1:
- In Marisol's 1968 sculpture Mi Mama y Yo,
- gone are the types of pop culture references
- that made the Parisian-born Venezuelan American artist a star at the height of the pop art movement.
- gone are the types of pop culture references
Sentence 2:
- In (?) place
- is a far more personal subject:
- a sculptural depiction of the artist as a young girl with her mother.
- is a far more personal subject:
Understanding the Meaning
Let's start reading from the beginning:
The first sentence tells us about Marisol's sculpture and what's NOT in it:
- 'In Marisol's 1968 sculpture Mi Mama y Yo'
- This is setting the scene - we're talking about a specific artwork
- 'gone are the types of pop culture references'
- The pop culture references are absent from this sculpture
- Notice "types" is plural - we're talking about multiple kinds of references
- 'that made the Parisian-born Venezuelan American artist a star at the height of the pop art movement'
- These references had previously made her famous
- But they're gone from THIS sculpture
Now we move to the second sentence, and this is where we have the blank:
- 'In ______ place'
Let's look at our choices:
- A. its
- B. they're
- C. their
- D. it's
To see what works here, let's read the rest of the sentence and understand what it's saying:
- 'In ______ place is a far more personal subject'
- Something is replacing those pop culture references
- That something is "a far more personal subject"
- 'a sculptural depiction of the artist as a young girl with her mother'
- This is what the sculpture actually shows instead
What do we notice about the structure here?
- The phrase "in ______ place" is an expression meaning "instead" or "as a replacement"
- We're saying: instead of X, we now have Y
- Instead of the pop culture references, we have something personal
- This blank word needs to refer back to what was just mentioned:
- "the types of pop culture references"
- This is PLURAL (we're talking about "types" - multiple things)
- The word we need must be:
- Possessive (the expression is "in their place" or "in its place")
- Plural (to match "types of pop culture references")
Looking at our choices:
- "their" is possessive AND plural ✓
- "its" is possessive but singular ✗
- "they're" means "they are" (not possessive) ✗
- "it's" means "it is" (not possessive) ✗
So we need their - the plural possessive that correctly refers back to "types of pop culture references."
Grammar Concept Applied
Pronoun-Antecedent Agreement with Possessives
When you use a possessive pronoun, it must agree in number with the noun it refers back to (called the antecedent in grammar terms). Here's how it works:
Pattern 1: Plural antecedent → plural possessive
- The students submitted their projects.
- "students" = plural antecedent
- "their" = plural possessive
Pattern 2: Singular antecedent → singular possessive
- The company released its annual report.
- "company" = singular antecedent
- "its" = singular possessive
In our question:
- Antecedent: "the types of pop culture references" (PLURAL)
- Possessive needed: "their" (PLURAL)
- Result: "In their place is a far more personal subject"
Important distinction - Possessives vs. Contractions:
- their = possessive (belonging to them)
- they're = contraction (they are)
- its = possessive (belonging to it)
- it's = contraction (it is)
The idiom "in _____ place" (meaning "instead" or "as a replacement") always requires the possessive form, never a contraction.
its
✗ Incorrect
This is possessive but singular. Since the antecedent is "types of pop culture references" (plural), using "its" creates a pronoun-antecedent agreement error. "Its" would suggest we're replacing only one thing, not the multiple "types" mentioned.
they're
✗ Incorrect
This is a contraction meaning "they are." Using this would create "In they are place," which is grammatically nonsensical. The idiom requires a possessive form, not a verb phrase.
their
✓ Correct
Correct as explained in the solution above.
it's
✗ Incorrect
This is a contraction meaning "it is." Using this would create "In it is place," which is grammatically impossible. Additionally, even if we needed the possessive form "its," it would still be wrong because it's singular and the antecedent is plural.