In modern plays, actors typically won't acknowledge the ________ do so breaks the fourth wall, a metaphorical barrier between actors...
GMAT Standard English Conventions : (Grammar) Questions
In modern plays, actors typically won't acknowledge the ________ do so breaks the fourth wall, a metaphorical barrier between actors and audiences that allows viewers to suspend the knowledge that they're watching a staged performance.
Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?
Let's begin by understanding the meaning of this sentence. We'll use our understanding of pause points and segment the sentence as shown - understanding and assimilating the meaning of each segment bit by bit!
Sentence Structure
- In modern plays,
- actors
- typically won't acknowledge the audience [?]
- actors
- do so breaks the fourth wall,
- a metaphorical barrier
- between actors and audiences
- that allows viewers to suspend the knowledge
- that they're watching a staged performance.
- that allows viewers to suspend the knowledge
- between actors and audiences
- a metaphorical barrier
Understanding the Meaning
Let's start reading from the beginning:
The sentence begins with:
- 'In modern plays, actors typically won't acknowledge the audience'
- In theater performances today, the actors pretend the audience isn't there
- They don't look at or talk to the people watching
This is where we have the blank. Let's look at the choices:
- audience. As to
- audience to
- audience. To
- audience, to
So we're deciding about punctuation (period, comma, or nothing) and whether we need "As to" or just "to."
To see what works here, let's read the rest of the sentence and understand what it's saying!
The sentence continues:
- 'do so breaks the fourth wall'
- "do so" means "acknowledge the audience"
- "breaks the fourth wall" means it destroys that invisible barrier
- The "fourth wall" is explained next as a metaphorical barrier between actors and audiences
- 'that allows viewers to suspend the knowledge that they're watching a staged performance'
- This barrier lets the audience forget they're watching a play
- They can get absorbed in the story as if it's real
So the complete picture is:
- First statement: Actors don't acknowledge the audience
- Second statement: Doing so (acknowledging them) would break the fourth wall
What do we notice about the structure here?
Let's check if these are complete thoughts:
- First part: "actors typically won't acknowledge the audience"
- Subject: actors
- Verb: won't acknowledge
- This is a complete sentence - it can stand alone!
- Second part: "To do so breaks the fourth wall"
- Subject: "To do so" (the infinitive phrase is acting as the subject)
- Verb: breaks
- This is also a complete sentence - it can stand alone!
When we have two complete sentences, we need to separate them properly. We can't just run them together or connect them with only a comma.
The correct answer is C: audience. To
- The period properly separates the two complete sentences
- "To do so" begins the new sentence, explaining why actors don't acknowledge the audience
Grammar Concept Applied
Properly Separating Complete Sentences
When you have two complete sentences (called independent clauses in grammar terms) - each with its own subject and verb that could stand alone - you must separate them properly.
You CAN use:
- A period: This creates two separate sentences
- Example: "She loves theater. She attends plays weekly."
- A semicolon: This keeps them as one sentence but shows they're closely related
- Example: "She loves theater; she attends plays weekly."
- A comma + coordinating conjunction (for, and, nor, but, or, yet, so):
- Example: "She loves theater, and she attends plays weekly."
You CANNOT use:
- Just a comma - this creates a "comma splice" error
- Wrong: "She loves theater, she attends plays weekly."
- No punctuation - this creates a "run-on sentence" error
- Wrong: "She loves theater she attends plays weekly."
In this question:
- First complete sentence: "actors typically won't acknowledge the audience"
- Subject: actors | Verb: won't acknowledge
- Second complete sentence: "To do so breaks the fourth wall"
- Subject: To do so | Verb: breaks
- Note: An infinitive phrase like "To do so" can serve as the subject of a sentence!
- Correct separation: Use a period → "audience. To"
- "As to do so breaks the fourth wall" is grammatically incorrect
- "As to" doesn't work in this context - it would need to be followed by something like "whether" or "how," not an infinitive phrase acting as a subject
- The sentence becomes nonsensical
- Creates a run-on sentence
- "actors typically won't acknowledge the audience to do so breaks the fourth wall" runs two complete sentences together without any punctuation
- This violates the rule that independent clauses need proper separation
- The reader can't tell where one complete thought ends and another begins
- Correct as explained in the solution above.
- Creates a comma splice
- Two complete sentences cannot be joined with just a comma
- "actors typically won't acknowledge the audience, to do so breaks the fourth wall" incorrectly uses a comma to connect two independent clauses
- You'd need either a period, a semicolon, or a comma with a coordinating conjunction