In plant cells, numerous structures work together to sustain life. The chloroplast _____ an organelle responsible for photosynthesis, the process...
GMAT Standard English Conventions : (Grammar) Questions
In plant cells, numerous structures work together to sustain life. The chloroplast _____ an organelle responsible for photosynthesis, the process by which plants convert light energy into chemical energy stored in glucose molecules.
Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?
is
are
were
have been
Sentence Structure
Sentence 1:
- In plant cells,
- numerous structures work together
- to sustain life.
Sentence 2:
- The chloroplast [is/are/were/have been] an organelle
- responsible for photosynthesis,
- the process
- by which plants convert light energy
- into chemical energy
- stored in glucose molecules.
- into chemical energy
- by which plants convert light energy
- the process
- responsible for photosynthesis,
Understanding the Meaning
Let's start reading from the beginning.
The first sentence gives us the context:
- 'In plant cells, numerous structures work together to sustain life.'
- This is telling us that plant cells have many different structures, and they all collaborate to keep the plant alive.
Now the second sentence zooms in on one specific structure:
- 'The chloroplast _____'
Here's where we need to fill in the blank. Let's look at our choices:
- is (singular, present)
- are (plural, present)
- were (plural, past)
- have been (plural, present perfect)
What do we notice?
- Our subject is 'The chloroplast' - this is ONE organelle, so it's singular.
- The choices are asking us to pick between singular and plural verb forms, and also between different tenses.
Based on what we've read:
- 'The chloroplast' is singular (we're talking about one type of organelle)
- So we need a singular verb to match it.
- The sentence is making a definitional statement - explaining what a chloroplast IS (not was, not has been, but simply IS).
So we need: is - the singular present form that agrees with 'The chloroplast.'
Now let's read the rest to see the complete picture:
- 'an organelle responsible for photosynthesis, the process by which plants convert light energy into chemical energy stored in glucose molecules.'
The complete sentence is defining what a chloroplast is:
- It's an organelle (a specialized structure in cells)
- It's responsible for photosynthesis
- Photosynthesis is the process where plants turn light into stored chemical energy
The correct answer is A: is
Grammar Concept Applied
Matching Verbs to Their Subjects (Subject-Verb Agreement)
Verbs must agree with their subjects in number - meaning if you have a singular subject (one thing), you need a singular verb form, and if you have a plural subject (multiple things), you need a plural verb form.
This agreement rule (called subject-verb agreement in grammar terms) works like this:
Singular subject + singular verb:
- The chloroplast is an organelle
- The student works hard
- She has finished
Plural subject + plural verb:
- The chloroplasts are organelles
- The students work hard
- They have finished
In our question:
- Subject: "The chloroplast" = singular (one organelle)
- Verb needed: "is" = singular present form
- This creates proper agreement: "The chloroplast is an organelle"
Key principle: Always identify your true subject first, determine whether it's singular or plural, then choose the verb form that matches in number.
is
✓ Correct
Correct as explained in the solution above.
are
✗ Incorrect
- This is a plural verb form
- Our subject "The chloroplast" is singular (one organelle)
- You wouldn't say "The chloroplast are" - it creates a number agreement error
- Singular subjects need singular verbs
were
✗ Incorrect
- This is a plural past tense verb
- Two problems: First, "The chloroplast" is singular, not plural
- Second, we're making a definitional statement about what a chloroplast IS (present, timeless fact), not what it WAS (past)
- This creates both a number agreement error and an inappropriate tense shift
have been
✗ Incorrect
- This is a plural present perfect verb form
- "The chloroplast" is singular, so this creates a number agreement error
- Additionally, present perfect ("have been") suggests an ongoing action or state that started in the past, but we're simply defining what a chloroplast is right now
- The simple present "is" is more appropriate for stating facts and definitions