In studying bird migration patterns, researchers examine where certain species travel and how ______ Analysis of tracking data reveals that...
GMAT Standard English Conventions : (Grammar) Questions
In studying bird migration patterns, researchers examine where certain species travel and how ______ Analysis of tracking data reveals that these species navigate using both magnetic fields and visual landmarks.
Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?
do they navigate across continents.
do they navigate across continents?
they navigate across continents?
they navigate across continents.
Sentence Structure
First sentence:
- In studying bird migration patterns,
- researchers examine
- where certain species travel
- and how ______ [they navigate across continents] [?: question or statement? inverted or standard order?]
Second sentence:
- Analysis of tracking data reveals
- that these species navigate using both magnetic fields and visual landmarks.
Understanding the Meaning
Let's start reading from the beginning:
'In studying bird migration patterns, researchers examine where certain species travel and how ______'
So researchers are examining two things about bird migration:
- Where the birds go
- How they get there (navigate across continents)
Now here's where we have the blank. Let's look at our choices:
- A. do they navigate across continents.
- B. do they navigate across continents?
- C. they navigate across continents?
- D. they navigate across continents.
So we're deciding between:
- Word order: "do they navigate" vs. "they navigate"
- Punctuation: question mark vs. period
To see what works here, let's understand the structure of what we're reading!
The key is that word "examine":
- Researchers examine WHERE certain species travel
- Researchers examine HOW ______ across continents
These are questions being investigated, but they're embedded inside a statement about what researchers do.
Let's think about the difference:
- Direct question (standing alone): "How do they navigate?"
- Uses inverted order: "do they"
- Uses question mark
- Indirect question (embedded in a statement): "researchers examine how..."
- Uses standard order: "they navigate" (not "do they navigate")
- No question mark (because the whole sentence is a statement)
What do we notice about the structure here?
- This is an indirect question - it's part of the larger statement about what researchers examine
- Since it's embedded in a statement (not standing alone as a question), we need:
- Standard word order: "they navigate"
- A period (because the overall sentence is a statement)
So we need: they navigate across continents. (Choice D)
Let's read the second sentence to see the complete picture:
'Analysis of tracking data reveals that these species navigate using both magnetic fields and visual landmarks.'
This confirms we're in a passage making statements about research findings, not asking direct questions.
GRAMMAR CONCEPT APPLIED
Direct vs. Indirect Questions
When a question is embedded within a larger statement (called an indirect question in grammar terms), it follows different rules than a question standing alone:
Direct question (stands alone):
- "How do birds navigate?"
- Uses inverted word order: "do birds navigate"
- Ends with question mark
Indirect question (embedded in statement):
- "Researchers examine how birds navigate."
- Uses standard word order: "birds navigate" (not "do birds navigate")
- No question mark (the whole sentence is a statement)
Pattern with compound objects:
- "Scientists study where penguins breed and how they survive harsh winters."
- Both "where penguins breed" and "how they survive" are indirect questions
- Both use standard word order
- The sentence ends with a period
In this question:
- "researchers examine where certain species travel and how they navigate across continents."
- Both parts after "examine" are indirect questions
- Standard word order required: "they navigate" ✓
- Period at the end because it's a statement ✓
do they navigate across continents.
do they navigate across continents?
they navigate across continents?
they navigate across continents.