Inventor John Friedman created a prototype of the first flexible straw by inserting a screw into a paper straw and,...
GMAT Standard English Conventions : (Grammar) Questions
Inventor John Friedman created a prototype of the first flexible straw by inserting a screw into a paper straw and, using dental floss, binding the straw tightly around the _______ When the floss and screw were removed, the resulting corrugations in the paper allowed the straw to bend easily over the edge of a glass.
Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?
screw's thread's.
screws' threads.
screw's threads.
screws threads'.
Let's begin by understanding the meaning of this sentence. We'll use our understanding of pause points and segment the sentence as shown - understanding and assimilating the meaning of each segment bit by bit!
Sentence Structure
- Inventor John Friedman
- created a prototype of the first flexible straw
- by inserting a screw into a paper straw
- and, using dental floss,
- binding the straw tightly around the ______
- created a prototype of the first flexible straw
- When the floss and screw were removed,
- the resulting corrugations in the paper
- allowed the straw to bend easily over the edge of a glass.
- the resulting corrugations in the paper
Understanding the Meaning
Let's read from the beginning:
- 'Inventor John Friedman created a prototype of the first flexible straw'
- So we're learning about how the flexible straw was invented
- 'by inserting a screw into a paper straw'
- He started by putting a screw inside a paper straw
- Notice: "a screw" - just ONE screw
- 'and, using dental floss, binding the straw tightly around the ______'
Now here's where we need to fill in the blank. He's binding (wrapping) the straw tightly around something.
Let's look at our choices:
- A: screw's thread's
- B: screws' threads
- C: screw's threads
- D: screws threads'
What do we notice? They're all about the screw and its threads, but they differ in where the apostrophes go - which affects whether we're talking about one or multiple screws, and whether the threads possess something.
Based on what we've read:
- We know there's only ONE screw - the text said "a screw" and later says "the screw"
- So we need the singular possessive form: screw's (one screw possessing something)
- What does that screw possess? Its threads.
- Threads are the spiral grooves that wind around a screw
- A screw has multiple threads (not just one), so threads should be plural
- The threads themselves don't possess anything - they're just what's being wrapped around
- So "threads" should NOT have an apostrophe
So we need: screw's threads (the threads belonging to the one screw)
That's Choice C!
Now let's read the rest to see the complete picture:
- 'When the floss and screw were removed, the resulting corrugations in the paper allowed the straw to bend easily'
- After wrapping the floss tightly around the screw's grooves, they removed both items
- This left grooves (corrugations) in the paper
- These grooves let the straw bend
The complete meaning: Friedman wrapped a paper straw around the spiral threads of a screw using dental floss, and when he removed the screw and floss, the paper had grooves that allowed it to bend - creating the flexible straw!
GRAMMAR CONCEPT APPLIED
Using Possessive Forms with Singular Nouns
When something belongs to a single thing, we use the singular possessive form: add an apostrophe + s to the owner. The thing that's owned can be either singular or plural (and doesn't get an apostrophe unless it also owns something).
Pattern: [Single Owner]'s + [Thing(s) Owned]
Examples:
- The tree's branches
- One tree possesses multiple branches
- tree's = singular possessive
- branches = plural (no apostrophe because the branches don't own anything)
- The car's wheels
- One car possesses multiple wheels
- car's = singular possessive
- wheels = plural (no apostrophe)
- The building's windows
- One building possesses multiple windows
- building's = singular possessive
- windows = plural (no apostrophe)
In this question:
- The screw's threads
- One screw (mentioned as "a screw") possesses multiple threads
- screw's = singular possessive
- threads = plural, no apostrophe (the threads don't own anything)
Common mistake to avoid: Don't add an apostrophe to the second noun just because the first noun has one. Only use possessive form when something actually possesses/owns something else.
screw's thread's.
(screw's thread's):
✗ Incorrect
- While "screw's" is correct (showing one screw possessing something), "thread's" is wrong
- "Thread's" is possessive, suggesting the thread owns something
- But the threads don't possess anything here - they're simply what's being wrapped around
- This would leave us waiting for what the thread possesses, which never comes
screws' threads.
(screws' threads):
✗ Incorrect
- "Screws'" is the plural possessive form - meaning multiple screws possessing something
- But the passage clearly mentions "a screw" (singular) and later "the screw"
- Only ONE screw was used in this process, not multiple screws
- This creates a disagreement with the rest of the sentence
screw's threads.
✓ Correct
Correct as explained in the solution above.
screws threads'.
(screws threads'):
✗ Incorrect
- This is grammatically malformed in two ways
- "Screws" without an apostrophe would be just plural, not possessive - but we need to show the threads belong to the screw
- "Threads'" is possessive, suggesting the threads own something, which doesn't make sense here
- This creates a phrase that doesn't establish any clear possessive relationship