Photographer Ansel Adams's landscape portraits are iconic pieces of American art. However, many of the ______ of landscapes were intended...
GMAT Standard English Conventions : (Grammar) Questions
Photographer Ansel Adams's landscape portraits are iconic pieces of American art. However, many of the ______ of landscapes were intended not as art but as marketing; a concessions company at Yosemite National Park had hired Adams to take pictures of the park for restaurant menus and brochures.
Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?
photographer's early photo's
photographers early photo's
photographer's early photos
photographers early photos
Let's begin by understanding the meaning of this sentence. We'll use our understanding of pause points and segment the sentence as shown - understanding and assimilating the meaning of each segment bit by bit!
Sentence Structure
First sentence:
- Photographer Ansel Adams's landscape portraits
- are iconic pieces of American art.
Second sentence:
- However,
- many of the [?] early [?] of landscapes
- were intended not as art but as marketing;
- a concessions company at Yosemite National Park
- had hired Adams
- to take pictures of the park
- for restaurant menus and brochures.
- to take pictures of the park
- had hired Adams
- many of the [?] early [?] of landscapes
Understanding the Meaning
The first sentence tells us who we're talking about:
- Photographer Ansel Adams's landscape portraits are iconic pieces of American art.
- So we know Ansel Adams is a photographer
- His landscape portraits are famous works of art
Now the second sentence gives us a contrast:
- "However, many of the ______ of landscapes were intended not as art but as marketing"
This is where we have the blank. Let's look at the choices:
- All choices have: "early photo/photos of landscapes"
- What varies:
- photographer's vs. photographers (possessive vs. plural)
- photo's vs. photos (with or without apostrophe)
To see what works here, let's read the rest of the sentence and understand what it's saying!
The sentence continues:
- "a concessions company at Yosemite National Park had hired Adams to take pictures of the park for restaurant menus and brochures."
Now let's understand what this complete sentence is telling us:
- The contrast being set up:
- Adams's portraits are now considered iconic art
- BUT many of his early photographs of landscapes weren't meant to be art
- They were commissioned as marketing materials
- Who the photos belong to:
- The sentence is talking about Adams's photographs
- These are the photographer's (Adams's) early photos
- We're talking about one photographer (Adams), not multiple photographers
- How many photos:
- "Many of the photos" - clearly we're talking about multiple photographs
- We need the plural form of "photo"
What do we notice about what we need?
- For "photographer":
- We need to show the photos belong to the photographer (possession)
- It's one photographer (Adams) → singular possessive: photographer's
- For "photos":
- We're talking about multiple photographs → we need the plural form
- Plural nouns don't use apostrophes unless they're possessive
- Just add -s: photos (not photo's)
So we need: photographer's early photos
The correct answer is Choice C.
GRAMMAR CONCEPT APPLIED
Using Apostrophes: Possession vs. Plurality
Apostrophes serve specific purposes, and it's important not to confuse them:
For Possession (showing ownership):
When something belongs to someone or something, use apostrophe + s for singular nouns:
- the photographer's camera = the camera belonging to the photographer
- the artist's studio = the studio belonging to the artist
- In our sentence: "the photographer's early photos" = the early photos belonging to the photographer (Adams)
For Plurals (showing more than one):
When you simply have more than one of something, add -s or -es WITHOUT an apostrophe:
- photos, paintings, sculptures (NOT photo's, painting's, sculpture's)
- cameras, brushes, canvases (NOT camera's, brush's, canvas's)
- In our sentence: "early photos" = multiple photographs (plural, no apostrophe needed)
The Common Error:
Adding apostrophes to make plurals (sometimes called the "greengrocer's apostrophe") is incorrect. Remember:
- Apostrophes show possession or form contractions
- They do NOT make words plural
In this question:
We needed BOTH forms:
- "photographer's" (possessive - the photos belong to him)
- "photos" (plural - multiple photographs)
photographer's early photo's
✗ Incorrect
- "photographer's" is correct (shows the photos belong to the photographer)
- "photo's" is incorrect - this adds an apostrophe to make it plural, but apostrophes are for possession or contractions, not for making something plural
- We're talking about multiple photos, so we simply need "photos" without an apostrophe
photographers early photo's
✗ Incorrect
- "photographers" is incorrect - this plural form suggests multiple photographers, but we're only talking about Adams (one photographer). It's also missing the possessive apostrophe that would show the photos belong to him.
- "photo's" is incorrect for the same reason as Choice A - you don't use apostrophes to make plurals
photographer's early photos
✓ Correct
Correct as explained in the solution above.
photographers early photos
✗ Incorrect
- "photographers" is incorrect - again, this suggests multiple photographers when we're only discussing Adams. Even if this were meant as possessive, it's missing the apostrophe.
- "photos" is correct (proper plural form)