Research by linguist Sarah Thomason indicates that the degree of grammatical borrowing—the extent to which one language adopts structural features...
GMAT Standard English Conventions : (Grammar) Questions
Research by linguist Sarah Thomason indicates that the degree of grammatical borrowing—the extent to which one language adopts structural features from another—in a minority language spoken by fewer than 10,000 speakers ______ significantly greater than the borrowing observed in languages with over one million speakers.
Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?
having been
will be
being
to be
Sentence Structure
- Research by linguist Sarah Thomason
- indicates that
- the degree of grammatical borrowing—
- the extent to which one language adopts
- structural features from another—
- in a minority language
- spoken by fewer than 10,000 speakers
- [?] significantly greater
- than the borrowing observed in languages
- with over one million speakers.
- the degree of grammatical borrowing—
- indicates that
Understanding the Meaning
Let's start from the beginning:
'Research by linguist Sarah Thomason indicates that...'
- This research is showing us something - it indicates a finding.
- What does it indicate?
The sentence continues:
"the degree of grammatical borrowing—the extent to which one language adopts structural features from another—in a minority language spoken by fewer than 10,000 speakers"
- 'Grammatical borrowing'
- is when one language takes structural features from another language
- (the dashes give us a quick definition of this term)
- We're talking about the degree (the amount) of this borrowing
- specifically in minority languages -
- languages spoken by fewer than 10,000 people
Now here's where we need to fill in the blank:
- 'the degree...______ significantly greater than the borrowing observed in languages with over one million speakers.'
Let's look at our choices:
- having been
- will be
- being
- to be
Now, what do we notice about the structure here?
- The research "indicates that [something]"
- That "something" is a complete thought - a clause
- Within that clause, we have:
- Subject: "the degree of grammatical borrowing...in a minority language"
- [blank]
- What it equals: "significantly greater than..."
- This clause needs a main verb - a complete verb that can actually serve as the action/linking verb of this clause
- "having been" = a participle (can't be a main verb)
- "being" = a participle (can't be a main verb)
- "to be" = an infinitive (can't be a main verb)
- "will be" = a complete verb in future tense (CAN be a main verb)
So we need will be - it's the only form that can actually function as the main verb of this clause. The sentence is saying: research indicates that the degree will be significantly greater in minority languages than in major languages.
Grammar Concept Applied
Using Finite Verbs as Main Verbs in Clauses
When you have a clause (a group of words with a subject and verb that expresses a complete thought), it needs a finite verb - a verb form that shows tense and can function as the main verb (called a finite verb in grammar terms).
Finite verbs can serve as main verbs:
- is, are, was, were
- will be, would be
- has been, had been
- indicates, indicated
- Examples: "The study shows results." / "The data will be significant."
Non-finite verbs CANNOT serve as main verbs:
- Participles: being, having been, shown, indicating
- Infinitives: to be, to show, to indicate
- Examples: "The study being complete" (incomplete - needs finite verb)
"The study is complete" (has finite verb)
In this question:
- After "indicates that," we need a complete clause
- The clause structure is: [subject] + [verb] + [complement]
- "the degree" + [blank] + "significantly greater"
- Only "will be" is a finite verb that can serve as the main verb
- All other choices are non-finite forms that cannot function as main verbs
Verification Output
Content Genre: Humanities & Social Sciences
Grammar Concept Tested: Verb Tense/Form/Voice
Sentence Complexity: Complex
Pattern: B
having been
✗ Incorrect
- This is a perfect participle - a non-finite verb form
- It cannot serve as the main verb of a clause
- Using it would leave the clause incomplete: "the degree...having been significantly greater" has no actual main verb to make it a complete clause
will be
✓ Correct
Correct as explained in the solution above.
being
✗ Incorrect
- This is a present participle or gerund - a non-finite verb form
- Like "having been," it cannot function as the main verb of a clause
- It would create an incomplete structure without a finite verb to anchor the clause
to be
✗ Incorrect
- This is an infinitive form
- Infinitives cannot serve as the main verb of a clause - they serve other grammatical roles
- Using it would result in an incomplete clause structure