Researchers studying the 'terra-cotta army,' the thousands of life-size statues of warriors found interred near the tomb of Emperor Qin...
GMAT Standard English Conventions : (Grammar) Questions
Researchers studying the 'terra-cotta army,' the thousands of life-size statues of warriors found interred near the tomb of Emperor Qin Shi Huang of China, were shocked to realize that the shape of each statue's ears, like the shape of each person's ears, ________ unique.
Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?
are
is
were
have been
Let's begin by understanding the meaning of this sentence. We'll use our understanding of pause points and segment the sentence as shown - understanding and assimilating the meaning of each segment bit by bit!
Sentence Structure
- Researchers studying the 'terra-cotta army,'
- the thousands of life-size statues of warriors
- found interred near the tomb of Emperor Qin Shi Huang of China,
- the thousands of life-size statues of warriors
- were shocked to realize that
- the shape of each statue's ears,
- like the shape of each person's ears,
- [?] unique.
- the shape of each statue's ears,
Understanding the Meaning
Let's start reading from the beginning:
Researchers were studying the 'terra-cotta army' –
- This is that famous archaeological discovery of thousands of warrior statues.
- The sentence gives us more detail: 'the thousands of life-size statues of warriors found interred near the tomb of Emperor Qin Shi Huang of China.'
These researchers 'were shocked to realize that' – they discovered something surprising.
What was surprising? The sentence tells us in a subordinate clause:
- 'the shape of each statue's ears, like the shape of each person's ears, ______ unique.'
This is where we have the blank. Let's look at the choices:
- are (plural)
- is (singular)
- were (plural, past)
- have been (plural)
To see what works here, I need to figure out what the subject is in this clause.
Let's look carefully at this phrase:
- 'the shape of each statue's ears'
Now here's what we notice about the structure:
- 'The shape' is the main subject
- NOT 'ears' – that word appears in the prepositional phrase 'of each statue's ears'
- The prepositional phrase tells us WHICH shape we're talking about, but 'shape' is still the subject
- The phrase 'like the shape of each person's ears'
- is just a comparison, set off by commas
- This is telling us that statue ears are like human ears in this respect
- But this phrase doesn't change what the subject is
So the subject is 'the shape' – that's singular.
The sentence is saying: each individual statue has ears with a unique shape, just like each individual person has ears with a unique shape.
Since 'the shape' is singular, we need a singular verb.
Looking at our choices:
- 'are' – plural, doesn't match
- 'is' – singular, MATCHES ✓
- 'were' – plural, doesn't match
- 'have been' – plural, doesn't match
So we need is.
GRAMMAR CONCEPT APPLIED
Subject-Verb Agreement with Intervening Phrases
When a subject and verb are separated by prepositional phrases or descriptive phrases set off by commas, the verb must still agree with the actual subject, not with nouns that appear in those intervening phrases.
The pattern:
- Subject + prepositional phrase (of/with/for + noun) + verb
- The subject and verb must agree
- Ignore the noun in the prepositional phrase
Example 1:
- The box of chocolates is on the table
- Subject: "box" (singular)
- Prepositional phrase: "of chocolates"
- Verb: "is" (singular) ✓
- NOT "are" even though "chocolates" is plural
Example 2:
- The students in the classroom are studying
- Subject: "students" (plural)
- Prepositional phrase: "in the classroom"
- Verb: "are" (plural) ✓
In our question:
- "The shape of each statue's ears" + comma phrase + "is unique"
- Subject: "the shape" (singular)
- Prepositional phrase: "of each statue's ears"
- Comma phrase: "like the shape of each person's ears"
- Verb needed: "is" (singular) ✓
The words "ears" appear multiple times, but they're never the subject - they're always inside prepositional phrases describing which shape we're talking about.
are
✗ Incorrect
- This is a plural verb, but our subject is "the shape," which is singular
- Creates a subject-verb disagreement
- You might be tempted by this because "ears" appears twice nearby, but "ears" is never the subject here
is
✓ Correct
Correct as explained in the solution above.
were
✗ Incorrect
- This is plural (doesn't match the singular "shape")
- While it's past tense, and the researchers' discovery happened in the past, the fact being described (that ear shapes are unique) is a timeless truth, which is better expressed in present tense
have been
✗ Incorrect
- This is also plural and doesn't match the singular subject "the shape"
- The present perfect tense also isn't necessary here for a general truth