Responding to decades of urban sprawl and declining historic neighborhoods, city planners in Charleston—recipients of the 2019 National Preservation A...
GMAT Standard English Conventions : (Grammar) Questions
Responding to decades of urban sprawl and declining historic neighborhoods, city planners in Charleston—recipients of the 2019 National Preservation Award—studied and then adapted successful European conservation strategies _____ a comprehensive plan that has revitalized the downtown district.
Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?
creating
to create
created
and creating
Sentence Structure
- Responding to decades of urban sprawl and declining historic neighborhoods,
- city planners in Charleston—
- recipients of the 2019 National Preservation Award—
- studied and then adapted successful European conservation strategies
- (?) a comprehensive plan
- that has revitalized the downtown district.
- (?) a comprehensive plan
- city planners in Charleston—
Understanding the Meaning
Let's read from the beginning to understand what's happening.
'Responding to decades of urban sprawl and declining historic neighborhoods'
- This sets up the context—it's telling us what prompted the action.
- Urban sprawl means cities spreading out in uncontrolled ways,
- and historic neighborhoods were declining.
'city planners in Charleston—recipients of the 2019 National Preservation Award—'
- These are the people doing something about the problem.
- The part between the dashes just gives us extra information about them (they won an award).
'studied and then adapted successful European conservation strategies'
- Here's what the planners did: two main actions.
- First, they studied strategies from Europe.
- Then, they adapted those strategies (changed them to fit Charleston).
Now we reach the blank: 'strategies _____ a comprehensive plan that has revitalized the downtown district.'
This is where we have the blank. Let's look at the choices:
- creating
- to create
- created
- and creating
To see what works here, let's understand what the sentence is telling us about the relationship between these parts!
'a comprehensive plan that has revitalized the downtown district'
- This tells us about a plan—a complete, thorough plan.
- This plan has revitalized (brought new life to) downtown Charleston.
Now, what's the relationship between:
- 'adapted successful European conservation strategies'
- and 'a comprehensive plan'?
What do we notice about the structure here?
- The main actions of the sentence are 'studied' and 'adapted'—these are what the city planners DID.
- The comprehensive plan is not another separate action they took.
- Instead, it's the GOAL or PURPOSE of adapting those strategies.
- They adapted strategies FOR WHAT REASON? To create a plan.
- When we want to show the purpose or goal behind an action, we use the infinitive form: 'to + verb'
So we need: to create
This clearly expresses that creating the plan was the goal of adapting the strategies.
GRAMMAR CONCEPT APPLIED
Using Infinitives to Express Purpose or Goal
When you want to show WHY someone did something—what their goal or intended outcome was—you use an infinitive (called an infinitive of purpose in grammar terms). The pattern is: to + base form of verb
Pattern:
- Main action: She studied hard
- Purpose/goal: to pass the exam
- → "She studied hard to pass the exam"
Another example:
- Main action: The company invested in new technology
- Purpose/goal: to improve efficiency
- → "The company invested in new technology to improve efficiency"
In our question:
- Main action: city planners adapted successful European conservation strategies
- Purpose/goal: to create a comprehensive plan
- → "city planners adapted strategies to create a comprehensive plan"
The infinitive "to create" clearly signals that creating the plan was the intended outcome—the reason for adapting the strategies. This is much clearer than other verb forms that might suggest separate actions or unclear relationships.
creating
- This present participle would either try to modify "strategies" or act as another verb
- But it doesn't establish a clear purpose relationship
- The structure becomes unclear—is "creating" describing the strategies or adding another action?
- It fails to show that the plan was the GOAL of their work
to create
- Correct as explained in the solution above.
created
- This past tense verb would try to add a third main action
- But it's not properly connected to "studied and adapted"—you'd need coordination like "and created"
- Without proper connection, this creates a grammatical fragment
- It also doesn't express the purpose relationship needed here
and creating
- This attempts to coordinate three actions: "studied and adapted... and creating"
- But this breaks parallel structure—the first two verbs are past tense (studied, adapted), while "creating" is not
- It also misrepresents the meaning by suggesting they did three separate things
- Creating the plan wasn't a third independent action—it was the PURPOSE of adapting the strategies