Robin Wall Kimmerer of the Citizen Potawatomi Nation is a bryologist, a plant scientist who specializes in mosses. To Kimmerer,...
GMAT Standard English Conventions : (Grammar) Questions
Robin Wall Kimmerer of the Citizen Potawatomi Nation is a bryologist, a plant scientist who specializes in mosses. To Kimmerer, mosses are Earth's most adaptable plants: they can clone ______ enter a dormant state in times of drought, and grow in areas that don't have soil.
Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?
themselves;
themselves,
themselves. And
themselves
Let's begin by understanding the meaning of this sentence. We'll use our understanding of pause points and segment the sentence as shown - understanding and assimilating the meaning of each segment bit by bit!
Sentence Structure
- Robin Wall Kimmerer of the Citizen Potawatomi Nation is a bryologist
- a plant scientist who specializes in mosses
- To Kimmerer
- mosses are Earth's most adaptable plants
- they can clone themselves [?]
- enter a dormant state in times of drought
- and grow in areas that don't have soil
- mosses are Earth's most adaptable plants
- [?] = comma, semicolon, period + "And", or nothing
Understanding the Meaning
The first sentence introduces us to Robin Wall Kimmerer:
- She's from the Citizen Potawatomi Nation
- She's a bryologist - a plant scientist who specializes in mosses
The second sentence tells us Kimmerer's perspective:
- To Kimmerer, mosses are Earth's most adaptable plants
The colon signals that what follows will show us WHY mosses are so adaptable.
Now the sentence gives us examples of what mosses can do:
- 'they can clone themselves...'
This is where we have the blank. Let's look at the choices:
- Choice A: themselves;
- Choice B: themselves,
- Choice C: themselves. And
- Choice D: themselves (no punctuation)
To see what works here, let's read the rest of the sentence and understand what it's saying!
The sentence continues:
- 'enter a dormant state in times of drought, and grow in areas that don't have soil.'
Now let's understand what this complete structure is telling us:
- 'they can clone themselves'
- First ability showing adaptability
- 'enter a dormant state in times of drought'
- Second ability showing adaptability
- 'and grow in areas that don't have soil'
- Third ability showing adaptability
So the complete picture is:
- The sentence is listing three different abilities that demonstrate why mosses are so adaptable
- All three actions share the same structure - they all go with "they can"
What do we notice about the structure here?
- This is a list of three items in a series
- When we list three or more items, we separate them with commas
- The pattern is: item 1, item 2, and item 3
- In this sentence
- Item 1: clone themselves
- Item 2: enter a dormant state in times of drought
- Item 3: grow in areas that don't have soil
So we need Choice B (themselves,) - a comma after "themselves" to properly separate the first item from the second item in this three-part series.
GRAMMAR CONCEPT APPLIED
Using Commas to Separate Items in a Series
When you list three or more items (whether single words, phrases, or clauses), you need to separate them with commas. The pattern uses commas between items and "and" before the final item (this comma before "and" is called the Oxford comma or serial comma in grammar terms):
Pattern: Item 1, Item 2, and Item 3
Example with single words:
- The scientist studied mosses, ferns, and lichens.
Example with phrases (like our question):
- Mosses can clone themselves, enter a dormant state in times of drought, and grow in areas that don't have soil.
- Item 1: clone themselves
- Item 2: enter a dormant state in times of drought
- Item 3: grow in areas that don't have soil
Why this matters:
- The commas create clear separation between distinct items
- They help readers understand where one item ends and another begins
- They prevent confusion and maintain parallel structure in the list
In our question:
- The three abilities are all parallel verb phrases sharing "they can"
- Each needs to be separated from the next with a comma
- After "themselves" we need a comma to properly introduce the second ability in the series
themselves;
✗ Incorrect
- A semicolon is too strong a break here
- Semicolons separate independent clauses (complete thoughts) or items in complex lists with internal commas
- "enter a dormant state" isn't a complete thought - it's part of a series of actions all connected to "they can"
- Using a semicolon disrupts the unity of the list
themselves,
✓ Correct
Correct as explained in the solution above.
themselves. And
✗ Incorrect
- A period creates a full stop, making what follows a separate sentence
- But "And enter a dormant state in times of drought, and grow in areas that don't have soil" is not a complete sentence
- It lacks a subject and the helping verb "can"
- This creates a sentence fragment
themselves
✗ Incorrect
- No punctuation runs the items together: "clone themselves enter a dormant state"
- This violates the convention of separating items in a series
- It creates confusion about where one ability ends and the next begins
- Makes the sentence difficult to read and understand