Several advantages—the ability to react strongly with chip components, to avoid interference from other waves, and to be confined within...
GMAT Standard English Conventions : (Grammar) Questions
Several advantages—the ability to react strongly with chip components, to avoid interference from other waves, and to be confined within tiny circuits— ______ acoustic waves as a promising alternative to electrical waves for transmitting data on computer chips; as a result, researchers are invested in developing more acoustic wave–based chips.
Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?
have positioned
positioning
by positioning
having positioned
Sentence Structure
- Several advantages—
- the ability to react strongly with chip components,
- to avoid interference from other waves,
- and to be confined within tiny circuits—
- to electrical waves
- for transmitting data on computer chips;
- as a result,
- researchers are invested in developing more acoustic wave–based chips.
Understanding the Meaning
Let's start reading:
- 'Several advantages—'
- This introduces the subject - we're talking about advantages (more than one).
- 'the ability to react strongly with chip components, to avoid interference from other waves, and to be confined within tiny circuits—'
- These dashes set off a list that tells us WHAT those advantages are.
- Three specific abilities are listed here.
- After this list, the second dash closes, and we return to the main sentence.
This is where we have the blank. Let's look at the choices:
- have positioned
- positioning
- by positioning
- having positioned
To see what works here, let's read the rest of the sentence and understand what it's saying:
- '______ acoustic waves as a promising alternative to electrical waves for transmitting data on computer chips'
- This is saying that these advantages do something to acoustic waves—
- they establish or place them as a promising alternative.
- The second sentence adds: 'as a result, researchers are invested in developing more acoustic wave–based chips.'
- This confirms the consequence - because of these positioning advantages, researchers are pursuing this technology.
What do we notice about the structure here?
- 'Several advantages' is the subject of the sentence
- It's plural (more than one advantage)
- Even though there's a long descriptive list between the dashes, 'Several advantages' is still the subject that needs a verb.
- The sentence needs a main verb - the action that the subject performs
- The meaning is that these advantages have positioned (or established) acoustic waves as promising.
- This verb needs to match with 'Several advantages' (plural).
So we need a complete main verb that agrees with the plural subject.
The correct answer is A. have positioned.
- 'Have positioned' is a complete verb form (present perfect tense)
- 'Have' agrees with the plural subject 'Several advantages'
- It serves as the main verb the sentence needs to be complete
GRAMMAR CONCEPT APPLIED
Main Verbs and Finite Verb Forms
Every complete sentence must have a finite verb—a verb form that shows tense and can agree with the subject (called the main verb). Participle forms like -ing words or having + past participle cannot serve as main verbs by themselves.
Pattern with finite verb (complete sentence):
- Subject: Several advantages
- Main Verb: have positioned
- Complete thought: "Several advantages have positioned acoustic waves as promising"
Pattern with participle (incomplete - fragment):
- Subject: Several advantages
- Participle only: positioning (or having positioned, or by positioning)
- Incomplete: "Several advantages positioning acoustic waves..."
- This lacks a finite verb and doesn't express a complete thought
Why this matters for subject-verb agreement:
- Finite verbs must agree with their subjects in number
- "Several advantages" = plural subject → needs "have positioned" (plural form)
- Not "has positioned" (singular form)
Application to this question:
The dashes create a long interruption between the subject "Several advantages" and where the verb needs to go. But once we identify that "Several advantages" is the subject, we know we need:
- A finite verb (not a participle)
- One that agrees with the plural subject
- "Have positioned" is the only choice that meets both requirements
have positioned
✓ Correct
Correct as explained in the solution above.
positioning
✗ Incorrect
- This is a participle form that cannot serve as the main verb of the sentence on its own
- Using "positioning" would leave the sentence without a complete verb, creating a fragment
- The sentence would read "Several advantages... positioning acoustic waves..." which is incomplete
by positioning
✗ Incorrect
- This creates a prepositional phrase, not a verb
- It cannot function as the main verb the sentence needs
- This would also leave the sentence as a fragment without a main verb
having positioned
✗ Incorrect
- This is a perfect participle, which is used to show an action that happened before another action or to modify something
- It cannot serve as the main verb of a sentence on its own
- This would leave the sentence incomplete, without the finite verb it needs