Text 1
Stage lighting theorist Adolphe Appia was perhaps the first to argue that light must be considered alongside all the various elements of a stage to create a single, unified performance. Researcher Kelly Bremner, however, has noted that Appia lacked technical expertise in the use of light in the theater. As a result of Appia's inexperience, Bremner argues, Appia's theory of light called for lighting practices that weren't possible until after the advent of electricity around 1881.
Text 2
Adolphe Appia was not an amateur in the practice of lighting. Instead, it is precisely his exposure to lighting techniques at the time that contributed to his theory on the importance of light. When working as an apprentice for a lighting specialist in his youth, Appia observed the use of portable lighting devices that could be operated by hand. This experience developed his understanding of what was possible in the coordination of elements on the stage.

Question

Text 1

Stage lighting theorist Adolphe Appia was perhaps the first to argue that light must be considered alongside all the various elements of a stage to create a single, unified performance. Researcher Kelly Bremner, however, has noted that Appia lacked technical expertise in the use of light in the theater. As a result of Appia's inexperience, Bremner argues, Appia's theory of light called for lighting practices that weren't possible until after the advent of electricity around 1881.

Text 2

Adolphe Appia was not an amateur in the practice of lighting. Instead, it is precisely his exposure to lighting techniques at the time that contributed to his theory on the importance of light. When working as an apprentice for a lighting specialist in his youth, Appia observed the use of portable lighting devices that could be operated by hand. This experience developed his understanding of what was possible in the coordination of elements on the stage.

Accepted Answer

Appia likely gained a level of technical expertise during his time as an apprentice.

Answer

Many lighting technicians dismissed Appia's ideas about light on the stage.

Answer

Theater practitioners who worked with Appia greatly admired his work.

Answer

Appia was unfamiliar with the use of music and sound in theater.

Text from Passage	Analysis
Text 1: Appia was first to argue light must be considered alongside all stage elements for unified performance	What it says: Appia = 1st to say light + all stage elements = unified show. What it does: Introduces Appia and his main contribution. What it is: Background context
Bremner noted that Appia lacked technical expertise in use of light in theater	What it says: Bremner says Appia = no tech skills with lighting. What it does: Presents criticism contrasting with reputation. What it is: Critical claim
As result of inexperience, Appia's theory called for lighting practices not possible until after electricity around 1881	What it says: Bremner argues lack of experience made theory impractical until electricity. What it does: Explains consequences of claimed inexperience. What it is: Supporting evidence
Text 2: Appia was not an amateur in the practice of lighting	What it says: Appia not amateur in lighting practice. What it does: Directly contradicts Text 1 claim about expertise. What it is: Counter-claim
His exposure to lighting techniques contributed to his theory on importance of light	What it says: Exposure to techniques helped develop theory. What it does: Explains how experience informed theoretical work. What it is: Cause-effect explanation
Working as apprentice for lighting specialist, Appia observed portable lighting devices operated by hand	What it says: Youth apprenticeship with specialist, saw handheld lights. What it does: Provides specific evidence of technical training. What it is: Concrete evidence
This experience developed his understanding of stage coordination possibilities	What it says: Experience led to understanding of coordination. What it does: Connects training to theoretical insights. What it is: Impact conclusion

Text 1Stage lighting theorist Adolphe Appia was perhaps the first to argue that light must be considered alongside all the...

GMAT Craft and Structure : (Structure) Questions

Text 1

Text 2

Step 1: Decode and Map the Passage

Create Passage Analysis Table

Step 2: Interpret the Question Precisely

Step 3: Prethink the Answer