The alga species Chlorella vulgaris is very efficient at making oxygen. For this reason, scientists are currently exploring ways to...
GMAT Standard English Conventions : (Grammar) Questions
The alga species Chlorella vulgaris is very efficient at making oxygen. For this reason, scientists are currently exploring ways to use this species in space. C. vulgaris might be used, for example, to build future biological air exchange systems that _______ oxygen for astronauts.
Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?
are producing
produced
produce
have produced
Sentence Structure
- Sentence 1:
- The alga species Chlorella vulgaris
- is very efficient at making oxygen.
- The alga species Chlorella vulgaris
- Sentence 2:
- For this reason,
- scientists
- are currently exploring ways to use this species in space.
- scientists
- For this reason,
- Sentence 3:
- C. vulgaris might be used,
- for example,
- to build future biological air exchange systems
- that (?) oxygen for astronauts.
- C. vulgaris might be used,
- Blank: (?) = are producing / produced / produce / have produced
Understanding the Meaning
Let's read through and understand what's being said:
The first sentence tells us:
- The alga species Chlorella vulgaris is very efficient at making oxygen.
- So we have an algae that's really good at producing oxygen.
The second sentence:
- For this reason, scientists are currently exploring ways to use this species in space.
- Because it makes oxygen so well, scientists want to figure out how to use it in space.
Now the third sentence gives us an example:
- C. vulgaris might be used, for example, to build future biological air exchange systems...
Now here's where we need to fill in the blank:
- "systems that ______ oxygen for astronauts"
Let's look at our choices:
- The choices give us different forms of a verb: are producing, produced, produce, have produced
- What varies is the tense and form
What do we know?
- The verb's subject is "systems" - from "biological air exchange systems that ______"
- "that" refers back to "systems"
- "systems" is plural, so we need a plural verb
- These are "future biological air exchange systems"
- They don't exist yet
- The sentence is describing what these systems would do - their function
- When we describe what something does as its basic function or purpose, we use simple present tense, even when talking about future things.
- Like: "We'll build a machine that processes data" (not "will process" or "is processing")
So we need:
- Simple present tense (to describe the function)
- Plural form (to match "systems")
- That's "produce"
The answer is C: "systems that produce oxygen for astronauts"
GRAMMAR CONCEPT APPLIED
Using Simple Present Tense to Describe Functions and Characteristics
When you describe what something does as its basic function or characteristic - even if you're talking about something in the future - you use simple present tense. The verb must agree in number with what it's describing.
The pattern:
- [Noun] + that + [simple present verb matching in number]
Examples:
- Future context, but describing function:
- "Next year we'll install a system that filters water"
- "filters" is simple present (even though the system doesn't exist yet)
- We're describing what the system does - its function
- With plural noun:
- "They're designing robots that perform surgery"
- "perform" is simple present plural
- Matches the plural "robots"
In our question:
- "future biological air exchange systems that produce oxygen"
- "produce" is simple present plural
- Matches "systems" (plural)
- Describes the function of these systems
- Works even though we're talking about future systems
This is different from describing a specific action happening at a specific time, where you would need other tenses (past, future, progressive, etc.).
are producing
✗ Incorrect
- This is present progressive, suggesting an action happening right now
- Doesn't fit because these are future systems that don't exist yet
- We're describing their function/purpose, not a temporary ongoing action
produced
✗ Incorrect
- This is past tense
- Doesn't work because these are future systems
- They can't have done something in the past when they haven't been built yet
produce
✓ Correct
Correct as explained in the solution above.
have produced
✗ Incorrect
- This is present perfect, indicating an action that started in the past and is relevant now
- Doesn't work because these systems don't exist yet
- They can't have completed any action when they're still hypothetical future systems