The archaeological museum in Athens houses artifacts from numerous ancient civilizations. One particular exhibit, the Minoan collection, _____ both ev...
GMAT Standard English Conventions : (Grammar) Questions
The archaeological museum in Athens houses artifacts from numerous ancient civilizations. One particular exhibit, the Minoan collection, _____ both everyday pottery from common households and elaborate ceremonial objects from royal palaces.
Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?
to contain
contains
containing
having contained
Let's begin by understanding the meaning of this sentence. We'll use our understanding of pause points and segment the sentence as shown - understanding and assimilating the meaning of each segment bit by bit!
Sentence Structure
- The archaeological museum in Athens
- houses artifacts
- from numerous ancient civilizations.
- houses artifacts
- One particular exhibit,
- the Minoan collection,
- [? to contain / contains / containing / having contained] both everyday pottery
- from common households
- and elaborate ceremonial objects
- from royal palaces.
Understanding the Meaning
Let's start from the beginning:
The first sentence gives us context:
- 'The archaeological museum in Athens houses artifacts from numerous ancient civilizations.'
- This is setting the scene - we're talking about a museum with ancient artifacts.
Now the second sentence focuses on something more specific:
- 'One particular exhibit, the Minoan collection...'
- We're zooming in on one specific exhibit
- 'the Minoan collection' is telling us which exhibit we're talking about
This is where we have the blank.
Let's look at the choices:
- to contain
- contains
- containing
- having contained
The choices are showing us different verb forms. To see what works here, let's read the rest of the sentence and understand what it's saying!
The sentence continues:
- '_____ both everyday pottery from common households and elaborate ceremonial objects from royal palaces.'
- This is describing what the exhibit has in it
- It includes both regular pottery from normal homes AND fancy ceremonial items from palaces
So the complete picture is:
- We have a specific exhibit (the Minoan collection)
- The sentence is telling us what this exhibit has in it
What do we notice about the structure here?
- The subject of this sentence is 'One particular exhibit'
- 'the Minoan collection' is just giving us more detail about which exhibit - it's extra information set off by commas
- The true subject is 'One particular exhibit' (singular)
- This sentence needs a main verb - the action that tells us what the exhibit does
- The sentence is fundamentally about what the exhibit contains
- Looking at our choices:
- 'to contain' - this is an infinitive form (to + verb) - it can't work as the main verb on its own
- 'containing' - this is an -ing form that needs a helping verb like 'is' - can't stand alone as the main verb
- 'having contained' - this is also a form that can't work as the main verb by itself
- 'contains' - this is a complete verb form that can serve as the main verb
- Plus, 'contains' agrees with our singular subject 'One particular exhibit'
So we need contains - it's the only form that works as a main verb and agrees with the singular subject.
GRAMMAR CONCEPT APPLIED
Main Verbs vs. Other Verb Forms
Every complete sentence needs a main verb - a verb form that can stand on its own to express the primary action or state. Not all verb forms can serve as main verbs:
Forms that CAN work as main verbs:
- Present tense: contains, houses, includes
- Past tense: contained, housed, included
- (These are called finite verbs in grammar terms)
Forms that CANNOT work as main verbs alone:
- Infinitives: to contain, to house, to include
- Present participles: containing, housing, including
- Perfect participles: having contained, having housed, having included
- (These are called non-finite verbs in grammar terms)
In this question:
- Subject: "One particular exhibit" (singular)
- Note: "the Minoan collection" is just extra information set off by commas
- Needed: A main verb that agrees with this singular subject
- Answer: contains - present tense, third person singular form
The pattern to remember:
When filling in a verb, ask yourself:
- Can this verb form serve as the main verb of the sentence?
- Does it agree with the subject in number (singular/plural)?
If you see forms like "to ___," "___ing," or "having ___ed" standing alone where a main verb should be, they'll create sentence fragments.
to contain
✗ Incorrect
- This is an infinitive form (to + verb)
- It cannot function as the main verb of a sentence on its own
- Would create a sentence fragment: "One particular exhibit...to contain both everyday pottery..." doesn't form a complete thought
- We need an actual verb, not an infinitive
contains
✓ Correct
- Correct as explained in the solution above.
containing
✗ Incorrect
- This is a present participle (-ing form)
- It cannot work as the main verb without a helping verb like "is"
- Would create a sentence fragment: "One particular exhibit...containing both everyday pottery..." is incomplete
- We'd need to say "is containing" for it to work as a verb, but that's not an option
having contained
✗ Incorrect
- This is a perfect participle form
- Like the other wrong choices, it cannot serve as the main verb on its own
- Would create a sentence fragment: "One particular exhibit...having contained both everyday pottery..." is incomplete
- This form typically describes background action or needs a helping verb