The Community Arts Initiative launched several programs in 2018 to increase access to creative education in underserved neighborhoods. The workshops...
GMAT Standard English Conventions : (Grammar) Questions
The Community Arts Initiative launched several programs in 2018 to increase access to creative education in underserved neighborhoods. The workshops and mentorship sessions _____ particularly effective in engaging young artists, many of whom have continued their creative pursuits professionally.
Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?
was
has been
were
are
Let's begin by understanding the meaning of this sentence. We'll use our understanding of pause points and segment the sentence as shown - understanding and assimilating the meaning of each segment bit by bit!
Sentence Structure
- The Community Arts Initiative launched several programs in 2018
- to increase access to creative education
- in underserved neighborhoods.
- to increase access to creative education
- The workshops and mentorship sessions [were/was/has been/are] (?) particularly effective
- in engaging young artists,
- many of whom have continued their creative pursuits professionally.
- in engaging young artists,
Understanding the Meaning
Let's start with the first sentence to get our context:
- "The Community Arts Initiative launched several programs in 2018"
- This organization started programs at a specific time in the past
- The purpose was "to increase access to creative education in underserved neighborhoods"
Now the second sentence tells us about how those programs worked out:
- "The workshops and mentorship sessions..."
- These are the specific programs being discussed
- Notice we have TWO things here: workshops AND mentorship sessions
This is where we have the blank. Let's look at our choices:
- Choice A: was
- Choice B: has been
- Choice C: were
- Choice D: are
So we're choosing the right form of the verb "to be." To see what works here, let's think about what we know and then read the rest!
What do we notice about the subject?
- "The workshops and mentorship sessions" is our subject
- We have two plural things: workshops (plural) and mentorship sessions (plural)
- They're joined by "and"
- When you connect two things with "and," you're talking about BOTH of them together
- So we need a PLURAL verb
This means we need "were" or "are" (the plural options), not "was" or "has been" (singular forms).
Now, which tense do we need? Let's look at our context:
- The first sentence tells us the Initiative "launched" these programs "in 2018"
- "Launched" is past tense
- "In 2018" is a specific time in the past
- So we're talking about how these programs performed back then, in the past
- We need past tense: "were"
The correct answer is Choice C: were
The rest of the sentence confirms this makes sense:
- "...were particularly effective in engaging young artists"
- The programs were successful at engaging artists
- "many of whom have continued their creative pursuits professionally"
- And the results have lasted - those artists are still pursuing their work now
GRAMMAR CONCEPT APPLIED
Subject-Verb Agreement with Compound Subjects and Tense Consistency
When you have two subjects joined by "and," they work together as a plural subject, and your verb must be plural to match:
Example 1: Compound subject
- Single: "The workshop was effective"
- Compound: "The workshop and the mentorship session were effective"
- "workshop and session" = plural subject
- "were" = plural verb form
Example 2: Tense consistency
- When context establishes a time frame, your verbs should match
- "The Initiative launched programs in 2018" → past tense
- "The workshops were effective" → past tense to match
- NOT: "The workshops are effective" → present tense doesn't match the past context
In our question:
- Subject: "The workshops and mentorship sessions" (two things joined by "and" = plural)
- Context: "launched...in 2018" (past tense established)
- Correct verb: "were" (plural + past tense)
was
✗ Incorrect
- This is a singular verb form, but our subject is plural: "The workshops and mentorship sessions" (two things joined by "and")
- Creates a subject-verb agreement error - you wouldn't say "The workshops and sessions was effective"
has been
✗ Incorrect
- This is also singular ("has" only works with singular subjects)
- Creates the same subject-verb agreement error as Choice A
- Additionally, the present perfect tense ("has been") doesn't fit well with the specific past time frame of "2018"
were
✓ Correct
Correct as explained in the solution above.
are
✗ Incorrect
- This IS plural, which would match our subject
- However, it's present tense, suggesting the workshops are happening right now
- But the context makes clear these programs were "launched in 2018" (past tense), so we're describing something that happened in the past, not something ongoing now