The decorative pottery was originally attributed to Roman craftsmen. However, recent analysis suggests that the work _____ more likely produced...
GMAT Standard English Conventions : (Grammar) Questions
The decorative pottery was originally attributed to Roman craftsmen. However, recent analysis suggests that the work _____ more likely produced by local artisans in the region.
Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?
to be
is
being
having been
Let's begin by understanding the meaning of this sentence. We'll use our understanding of pause points and segment the sentence as shown - understanding and assimilating the meaning of each segment bit by bit!
Sentence Structure
- The decorative pottery
- was originally attributed to Roman craftsmen.
- However,
- recent analysis
- suggests
- that the work [?] more likely produced by local artisans in the region.
- suggests
Understanding the Meaning
The first sentence sets up the background:
- 'The decorative pottery was originally attributed to Roman craftsmen.'
- This pottery was thought to be made by Roman craftsmen.
Now the second sentence introduces new information:
- 'However, recent analysis suggests that...'
- The word "However" signals a contrast
- New analysis is revealing something different
This is where we have the blank. Let's look at the choices:
- to be / is / being / having been
- These are all different forms of the verb "to be"
To see what works here, let's read the rest of the sentence and understand what it's saying!
- 'that the work _____ more likely produced by local artisans in the region.'
Now let's understand what this structure is telling us:
- 'produced by local artisans'
- The word "by" signals that someone is doing the producing
- This is a passive construction - the work is being produced BY artisans
- In passive voice, we need: a form of "be" + past participle
- The structure is: "the work [form of be] produced by local artisans"
- We need a form of "be" to complete the passive voice
- 'more likely' sits in the middle as a modifier
- It means "with greater probability"
- The full phrase is: "the work [be] more likely produced"
What do we notice about what we need here?
- After "suggests that," we need a complete clause with a proper verb
- Not an infinitive (to be)
- Not a participle (being, having been)
- We need a conjugated, finite verb
- The subject is "the work" - singular
- The reporting verb "suggests" is in present tense
- So we need present tense in the clause
So we need: is - the simple present form that makes "is produced" a complete passive construction.
The correct answer is Choice B: "the work is more likely produced by local artisans."
GRAMMAR CONCEPT APPLIED
Finite Verbs in "That" Clauses After Reporting Verbs
When you have a reporting verb (like "suggests," "believes," "thinks," "says") followed by "that," the clause after "that" needs a complete verb - specifically, a finite verb (called this because it shows person, number, and tense). This is different from infinitives or participles.
Pattern:
- Reporting verb + that + subject + finite verb
- She suggests that the answer is correct. ✓
- She suggests that the answer to be correct. ✗ (infinitive - incomplete)
- She suggests that the answer being correct. ✗ (participle - incomplete)
In our question:
- Recent analysis suggests that the work is more likely produced...
- "suggests" = reporting verb
- "that" introduces the clause
- "the work" = subject of the clause
- "is" = finite verb (present tense, singular, third person)
- "is produced" = passive voice construction (form of be + past participle)
Why we need "is" specifically:
- The subject "the work" is singular → needs singular verb
- The reporting is in present tense ("suggests") → present tense fits
- Passive voice requires: form of "be" + past participle → "is produced"
to be
✗ Incorrect
- "the work to be more likely produced" - This creates an infinitive form
- After "suggests that," we need a complete clause with a conjugated verb, not an infinitive
- This makes the clause incomplete and ungrammatical
is
✓ Correct
Correct as explained in the solution above.
being
✗ Incorrect
- "the work being more likely produced" - "Being" is a participle form, not a finite verb
- After "suggests that," we need a complete clause with a conjugated verb
- This creates a fragment rather than a complete thought
having been
✗ Incorrect
- "the work having been more likely produced" - "Having been" is a perfect participle, not a finite verb
- Like "being," this doesn't provide the conjugated verb needed after "suggests that"
- This creates an incomplete clause structure