The establishment of Hull House in Chicago in 1889 offered essential social services to struggling immigrant communities and _____ a...
GMAT Standard English Conventions : (Grammar) Questions
The establishment of Hull House in Chicago in 1889 offered essential social services to struggling immigrant communities and _____ a transformative model for the settlement house movement that spread across urban America.
Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?
creating
had created
create
created
Let's begin by understanding the meaning of this sentence. We'll use our understanding of pause points and segment the sentence as shown - understanding and assimilating the meaning of each segment bit by bit!
Sentence Structure
- The establishment of Hull House in Chicago in 1889
- offered essential social services
- to struggling immigrant communities
- and
- (?) a transformative model
- for the settlement house movement
- that spread across urban America.
- for the settlement house movement
- offered essential social services
Understanding the Meaning
Let's read from the beginning and understand what this sentence is telling us:
- 'The establishment of Hull House in Chicago in 1889'
- This is talking about when Hull House was founded - in Chicago, in 1889.
- 'The establishment' is our subject - the founding/creation of this place.
- 'offered essential social services to struggling immigrant communities'
- This tells us the first thing the establishment of Hull House did.
- It provided important services to immigrant communities who were struggling.
- 'and'
- This connecting word tells us we're about to hear a second thing the establishment did.
Now here's where we need to fill in the blank:
- '_____ a transformative model for the settlement house movement'
Let's look at our choices:
- We're deciding between different forms of the verb "create": creating, had created, create, created
What do we need here? Let's think about what we've seen so far:
- One subject: "the establishment"
- Two actions connected by "and":
- offered essential social services
- [blank] a transformative model
When you have one subject doing two things connected by "and," those actions need to match in form. This creates balance in the sentence.
- "offered" is in past tense (it happened in 1889)
- So we need the second verb also in past tense: "created"
So we need created (Choice D).
Now let's read the rest to see the complete picture:
- 'that spread across urban America'
- This tells us more about the settlement house movement - it spread across cities in America.
The complete meaning is:
- When Hull House was established in 1889, it did two important things:
- It provided essential services to immigrant communities, AND
- It created a model that other settlement houses followed across America.
Grammar Concept Applied
Parallel Structure with Compound Verbs
When you have one subject performing multiple actions connected by "and" (this is called a compound predicate in grammar terms), those verbs need to be in the same form and tense to create parallel structure:
Pattern:
- Subject + Verb1 + and + Verb2
- Verb1 and Verb2 must match
Example 1:
- The scientist conducted experiments and published her findings.
- Both verbs in simple past
- Same subject doing two actions
Example 2 (Incorrect):
- The scientist conducted experiments and publishing her findings.
- "conducted" (past) doesn't match "publishing" (present participle)
- Breaks parallel structure
In our question:
- The establishment offered services and created a model.
- Both verbs in simple past tense
- Same subject ("the establishment") performing both actions
- Connected by "and"
- Perfect parallel structure
creating
✗ Incorrect
- This is a present participle form that doesn't match "offered"
- It would create an unbalanced structure: "The establishment offered...and creating" doesn't work grammatically
- The two verbs need to be in the same form to maintain parallel structure
had created
✗ Incorrect
- This is past perfect tense, which doesn't match "offered" (simple past)
- Past perfect is used when one past action happened before another past action, but that's not the case here
- Both actions (offering services and creating a model) happened at the same time in 1889
- This breaks the parallel structure needed when connecting two verbs with "and"
create
✗ Incorrect
- This is present tense, which doesn't match "offered" (past tense)
- It would mix time frames incorrectly: "The establishment offered...and create"
- This breaks parallel structure and creates tense disagreement
created
✓ Correct
Correct as explained in the solution above.