The First Folio, published in 1623, is the first collection of William Shakespeare's plays. The collection ________ 18 plays that...
GMAT Standard English Conventions : (Grammar) Questions
The First Folio, published in 1623, is the first collection of William Shakespeare's plays. The collection ________ 18 plays that might otherwise have been lost, such as Julius Caesar and Macbeth.
Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?
to be including
including
to include
includes
Sentence Structure
- The First Folio,
- published in 1623,
- is the first collection of William Shakespeare's plays.
- The collection [?] 18 plays
- that might otherwise have been lost,
- such as Julius Caesar and Macbeth.
- that might otherwise have been lost,
Understanding the Meaning
Let's start reading from the beginning:
The first sentence tells us:
- 'The First Folio, published in 1623, is the first collection of William Shakespeare's plays.'
- The First Folio is a book collection
- It was published in 1623
- It's the first time Shakespeare's plays were gathered together
Now the second sentence begins:
- 'The collection _____ 18 plays...'
This is where we have the blank. Let's look at our choices:
- A: "to be including"
- B: "including"
- C: "to include"
- D: "includes"
Now here's the key question: What does this sentence need?
- We have a subject: "The collection"
- After the subject, we need the main verb - the word that tells us what the collection DOES or what's TRUE about it
Let's test what we need:
- "The collection to be including..." - This doesn't make a complete sentence. "To be including" can't act as the main verb.
- "The collection including..." - "Including" here would just be a describing word, not the main verb doing the work of the sentence.
- "The collection to include..." - Again, "to include" is not a main verb form that can complete the sentence.
- "The collection includes..." - "Includes" is a proper main verb that tells us what the collection does!
So we need: includes - this is the main verb that works with the subject "The collection."
Now let's finish reading the sentence to get the complete picture:
- 'The collection includes 18 plays that might otherwise have been lost, such as Julius Caesar and Macbeth.'
- The collection contains 18 plays
- Without this collection, these plays might have been lost forever
- Examples: Julius Caesar and Macbeth
What do we notice about the structure here?
- The sentence has a clear subject ("The collection") that needs a main verb to express what it does
- Only a finite verb - one that can serve as the main action of the sentence - works here
- "Includes" is that finite verb, matching the singular subject "The collection"
The correct answer is D: includes
GRAMMAR CONCEPT APPLIED
Finite Verbs as Sentence Essentials
Every complete sentence needs a finite verb (called the main verb or predicate in grammar terms) - a verb form that can serve as the primary action or state of the sentence and agrees with the subject. Infinitives (to + verb) and participles (-ing or -ed forms used alone) cannot serve as the main verb.
The Pattern:
- Fragment (no finite verb): The company to expand operations
- "to expand" is an infinitive - cannot be the main verb
- Complete sentence (with finite verb): The company expands operations
- "expands" is a finite verb - serves as main verb
- Fragment (no finite verb): The report including new data
- "including" is a participle - cannot be the main verb alone
- Complete sentence (with finite verb): The report includes new data
- "includes" is a finite verb - serves as main verb
In this question:
- Subject: "The collection"
- Needed: A finite verb that tells what the collection does
- Answer: "includes" - a finite verb in present tense, third person singular
- Why it works: Provides the essential main verb the sentence requires and agrees with the singular subject
to be including
"to be including"
✗ Incorrect
- This is an infinitive construction (to + be + -ing form) that cannot serve as the main verb of a sentence
- "The collection to be including 18 plays..." creates a sentence fragment without a proper main verb
- The sentence would be incomplete and grammatically incorrect
including
"including"
✗ Incorrect
- This is a participle form (-ing form) that works as a modifier or describing word, not as a main verb
- "The collection including 18 plays..." would leave the sentence without a finite verb
- The sentence would be a fragment, missing its essential verb
to include
"to include"
✗ Incorrect
- This is an infinitive form (to + verb) that cannot function as the main verb of a sentence
- "The collection to include 18 plays..." is grammatically incomplete
- Creates a fragment rather than a complete sentence
includes
"includes"
✓ Correct
- Correct as explained in the solution above.