The Roman Forum was the center of ancient Rome's public life. It served as the gathering place _____ Archaeological evidence...
GMAT Standard English Conventions : (Grammar) Questions
The Roman Forum was the center of ancient Rome's public life. It served as the gathering place _____ Archaeological evidence reveals that citizens met there daily for commerce, political discourse, and religious ceremonies.
Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?
where citizens conducted civic affairs?
where citizens conducted civic affairs.
where did citizens conduct civic affairs.
where did citizens conduct civic affairs?
Let's begin by understanding the meaning of this sentence. We'll use our understanding of pause points and segment the sentence as shown - understanding and assimilating the meaning of each segment bit by bit!
Sentence Structure
Sentence 1:
- The Roman Forum
- was the center
- of ancient Rome's public life.
- was the center
Sentence 2:
- It
- served as the gathering place
- where citizens conducted/did citizens conduct civic affairs [?/.]
- served as the gathering place
- Archaeological evidence
- reveals
- that citizens met there daily
- for commerce, political discourse, and religious ceremonies.
- that citizens met there daily
- reveals
Understanding the Meaning
Let's start by reading the first sentence:
- "The Roman Forum was the center of ancient Rome's public life."
- This tells us what the Roman Forum was - the main hub for public activities.
Now the second sentence begins:
- "It served as the gathering place..."
- "It" refers back to the Roman Forum
- The sentence is telling us what function the Forum served
This is where we have the blank.
Let's look at the choices:
- A: where citizens conducted civic affairs?
- B: where citizens conducted civic affairs.
- C: where did citizens conduct civic affairs.
- D: where did citizens conduct civic affairs?
The choices vary on:
- Word order: "citizens conducted" vs. "did citizens conduct"
- Punctuation: period vs. question mark
To see what works here, let's read the rest and understand the complete structure!
The sentence continues: "Archaeological evidence reveals that citizens met there daily for commerce, political discourse, and religious ceremonies."
Now let's understand what we have:
- This is actually TWO SEPARATE SENTENCES
- First sentence: "It served as the gathering place ___"
- Second sentence: "Archaeological evidence reveals..."
So the blank needs to complete the first sentence.
What do we notice about the structure?
The phrase in the blank is describing "the gathering place":
- It's telling us WHICH gathering place - the one where citizens conducted civic affairs
- This is a descriptive clause that modifies the noun "place"
Think about it this way:
- We're not ASKING "Where did citizens conduct civic affairs?"
- We're STATING what the Forum was: "It was the gathering place where citizens conducted civic affairs"
When "where" introduces a descriptive clause (not a direct question), we use statement word order:
- Statement order: "where citizens conducted" ✓
- Question order: "where did citizens conduct" ✗
And since this is a declarative statement (telling us what the Forum was, not asking a question), it needs a period, not a question mark.
The correct answer is B: "where citizens conducted civic affairs."
- Uses statement word order for the descriptive clause
- Ends with a period because it's a declarative statement
GRAMMAR CONCEPT APPLIED
Descriptive Clauses vs. Direct Questions: When "Where" Describes vs. Asks
The word "where" can introduce two different types of structures, and the word order tells you which one you're dealing with:
Type 1: Descriptive Clause (also called a relative clause in grammar terms)
- Modifies or describes a place noun
- Uses statement word order: subject + verb
- Example: "the restaurant where we ate dinner"
- Not asking anything - just describing which restaurant
- Statement order: "we ate" (not "did we eat")
Type 2: Direct Question
- Asks for location information
- Uses question word order: auxiliary verb + subject + main verb
- Example: "Where did we eat dinner?"
- Asking for information
- Question order: "did we eat" with question mark
In this question:
- "It served as the gathering place where citizens conducted civic affairs."
- This is Type 1 - a descriptive clause
- "Where citizens conducted civic affairs" describes "the gathering place"
- Uses statement word order: "citizens conducted" ✓
- Ends with period because the whole sentence is declarative ✓
Key principle: When "where" is describing a place (not asking a question), use statement word order and match your punctuation to the sentence type (declarative = period).
where citizens conducted civic affairs?
✗ Incorrect
- Incorrectly uses a question mark for a declarative statement
- The sentence is telling us what the Forum was, not asking a question
- "It served as the gathering place where citizens conducted civic affairs?" doesn't make logical sense as a question
- Question marks should only end interrogative sentences, not declarative statements
where citizens conducted civic affairs.
✓ Correct
- Correct as explained in the solution above.
where did citizens conduct civic affairs.
✗ Incorrect
- Uses question word order ("did citizens conduct") but ends with a period
- Creates a grammatical mismatch between structure and punctuation
- In a descriptive clause modifying a noun, we need statement word order ("citizens conducted"), not question structure
- The period is correct, but the word order is wrong
where did citizens conduct civic affairs?
✗ Incorrect
- Uses both question word order AND question mark punctuation
- You cannot embed a complete question structure into the middle of a declarative sentence this way
- "It served as the gathering place where did citizens conduct civic affairs?" is ungrammatical
- Descriptive clauses require statement word order, not question structure