The village of Panduyacu in Ecuador _______ one of the rare places in the world located almost directly on the...
GMAT Standard English Conventions : (Grammar) Questions
The village of Panduyacu in Ecuador _______ one of the rare places in the world located almost directly on the equator.
Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?
are being
have been
is
are
Let's begin by understanding the meaning of this sentence. We'll use our understanding of pause points and segment the sentence as shown - understanding and assimilating the meaning of each segment bit by bit!
Sentence Structure
- The village
- of Panduyacu
- in Ecuador
- [?] one of the rare places
- in the world
- located almost directly on the equator.
Understanding the Meaning
Let's start reading from the beginning:
'The village of Panduyacu in Ecuador'
We're talking about a specific village:
- Which village? - Panduyacu
- Where is it? - in Ecuador
So our subject is 'the village' - it's ONE village we're discussing.
Now here's where we need to fill in the blank:
- 'The village of Panduyacu in Ecuador ______ one of the rare places...'
Let's look at our choices:
- are being (plural)
- have been (plural)
- is (singular)
- are (plural)
What do we notice?
- The subject of the sentence is 'the village' - that's singular.
- 'Of Panduyacu' and 'in Ecuador' are phrases that describe WHICH village and WHERE it is, but they don't change the fact that we're still talking about ONE village.
- A singular subject needs a singular verb.
So we need C. is - the singular form that matches 'village.'
Now let's read the rest to see the complete picture:
'one of the rare places in the world located almost directly on the equator.'
The complete meaning is:
- This village IS one of the rare places in the world that sits almost directly on the equator.
- We're stating a fact about what makes this village special - its location on the equator.
GRAMMAR CONCEPT APPLIED
Subject-Verb Agreement with Intervening Phrases
The verb in a sentence must agree in number with its subject - singular subjects take singular verbs, plural subjects take plural verbs. The tricky part? Sometimes phrases come between the subject and verb that can distract you.
The key is to identify the true subject and ignore the prepositional phrases (phrases that start with words like 'of,' 'in,' 'with,' 'for') that might separate the subject from the verb.
Pattern:
- Singular subject + [prepositional phrase(s)] + singular verb
- Plural subject + [prepositional phrase(s)] + plural verb
Examples:
- The box [of chocolates] is on the table.
- Subject: box (singular)
- Ignore: of chocolates (prepositional phrase)
- Verb: is (singular)
- The students [in the classroom] are studying.
- Subject: students (plural)
- Ignore: in the classroom (prepositional phrase)
- Verb: are (plural)
In this question:
- The village [of Panduyacu] [in Ecuador] is one of the rare places...
- Subject: village (singular)
- Ignore: of Panduyacu, in Ecuador (prepositional phrases)
- Verb: is (singular) ✓
The phrases 'of Panduyacu' and 'in Ecuador' tell us more about the village, but the core sentence is still 'The village is one of the rare places...'
are being
✗ Incorrect
- Uses the plural verb 'are' which doesn't agree with the singular subject 'village'
- The progressive form 'being' suggests an ongoing change, but we're stating a permanent fact about the village's geographic location
have been
✗ Incorrect
- Uses the plural verb 'have' which doesn't agree with the singular subject 'village'
- The present perfect tense is unnecessary here - we're simply stating what the village is, not describing a state that has continued over time
is
✓ Correct
Correct as explained in the solution above.
are
✗ Incorrect
- Uses the plural verb 'are' which doesn't agree with the singular subject 'village'
- Students might be distracted by 'Panduyacu' or 'Ecuador' in the middle, but these are just prepositional phrases describing the village - they don't make the subject plural